2012-11-03, 19:55 | Link #31081 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2012
|
Quote:
He was there the whole time. People believe he is alive when he is dead, the body has gotta be somewhere seeing that he was used as a fake victim. And wasn't it that whenever used as fake victim it was in the Main Mansion which is the closest to the Chapel? Hardly see him being left there let alone the Hidden Mansion. |
|
2012-11-03, 19:58 | Link #31082 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2011
|
Quote:
Quote:
So, although the Kyrie culprit isn't now the sole theory going on, people are considering the possibility she andRudolf were culprits while first it was dismissed as an incident. I see this as a worsening of the situation, not as an improving it. Quote:
There's to say Yasu is defined as shy and part of her message involves her having a wound that makes her body impossible to love so maybe she didn't feel like telling this openly. That and Ryukishi needed an excuse to set up his plot, which I find, in points like this one, a bit weak. |
|||
2012-11-03, 20:32 | Link #31083 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
|
Quote:
As for Kinzo in the chapel, sorry but All six were killed by other people we know from other ep's that Kinzo cannot be said to have died in this manner, and in fact likely died of natural causes. Also I didn't quite get the food thing. |
|
2012-11-03, 21:32 | Link #31084 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2011
|
Quote:
So should we assume Yasu killed him as well? Personally I can't say I was satisfied by how his dead was handled in EP 7 but I admit I've accepted it as natural... though maybe she killed him in the sense she refused to forgive him and this broke his heart more than she stabbed/poisoned/shoot/strangled/whatever him... |
|
2012-11-03, 23:19 | Link #31085 | |||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2010
|
Quote:
On a more semantic level, "the six" have to be dead upon discovery, and Kanon's case is arguable, but Genji and Rosa are never discovered dead in EP2, by your theory. The read about the six being "genuine victims" is a direct response to Battler's "One of the six was the culprit, and this person killed the other five, then pretended to be dead." Lets look back at some events. Quote:
Kyrie blurted out "I thought there was supposed to be a special guest", and didn't mention actually having SEEN her until Rosa claimed seeing her, first. Secondly, Ghoda never saw Beatrice. He was informed by Genji. Thirdly, Kumasawa knows as well, since she was in the kitchen during Ghoda's rant about it. Thirdly, Nanjo left because he did not belong in the adults discussion. The children were told to leave, and Nanjo announced he would go with them, in that order. Why would he stay around during the siblings arguments? Fourthly, though the passage of time is rather vague, everyone seemed to be well into their dinner. The kids all said they were in the process of eating, several lines refer to dinner "moving along", and Natsuhi makes a point of making sure dessert will be sent to the kids in the Guesthouse. Also, Jessica has several asthma attacks, unless you mean to say that Kratsuhi makes regular practice of poisoning their daughters, and only their daughters, food every now and then. Of course the ones remaining were the ones in the chapel - it's a consistent opening that the adults, or at least a lot of them, are killed together on the first night. They're always grouped together for the conference, and they would be the largest obstacle to the murders going off smoothly. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||||
2012-11-04, 00:36 | Link #31086 | |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Quote:
Likewise, Rudolf wouldn't have any reason to marry again that quickly unless he was under a particular deadline. What seemed to bother Battler was the suddenness of that action. Rudolf and Kyrie don't normally act hastily, so there'd have to be a reason for that. They have to marry fast or it will become increasingly obvious that Rudolf was cheating on his late wife. Unfortunately, by marrying fast they also become suspicious, although Battler seems to have missed the signals and assumed it was for a different reason. I forget how explicitly Kyrie brought this up, but I vaguely recall her dancing around the exact rationale in her talk with Jessica in Dawn. She may have said that outright at some point and I just forgot about it. Either way, it seems pretty obvious. Unfortunately it also makes Asumu's death seem incredibly convenient, which makes you wonder whether Kyrie was telling the truth that her death miraculously didn't require Kyrie to do anything. If it's true, then it becomes very suspicious as it means that Kyrie was essentially "blessed" by both Lambdadelta (with the certain will to kill Asumu) and Bernkastel (with the miracle that Asumu would die without Kyrie having to dirty her hands).
__________________
|
|
2012-11-04, 02:19 | Link #31087 |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
|
One thing that I find interesting about the chapel murder is it is one of the only places where everyone is confirmed to be dead and not the culprit.
There are 11 people left so 11 new possible theories. Shkanontrice - Canon Shannontrice - Easier more manageable version of Shkanon. Kanontrice - You just have to get past his deaths and you are golden. Funny enough Shannon is only said to be dead once in the story while Kanon is dead multiple times. Makes you wonder if Shannon's only death is her real death. Gohdatrice - Perfect Flawless theory. Genjitrice - Just no. If someone could work together a Genjitrice theory then I would be impressed. Kumasawatrice - Might be possible although Episode 1 is a problem. Nanjotrice - Works out pretty nice for 2-4 but Episode 1 is a problem. Georgetice - Not a bad candidate for the culprit. He always lives till near the end and is almost never confirmed dead. Jessicatrice - She's in the same boat as George. Mariatrice - Well she certainly almost always lives near the end but she almost always has an alibi. Considering this game is Japanese I wouldn't be surprised if the culprit was the creepy little girl. Rosatrice - Not going to talk about this. Regarding the whole motive for Kyrie, you would really only need a Motive for Rudolf considering Kyrie said she would do whatever Rudolf asked her to do EVEN MURDER her whole family. I feel like Ryukishi was having a field day when he wrote that line. |
2012-11-04, 03:20 | Link #31089 |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Kyrie also says, repeatedly, that she's always tried to be the brains for Rudolf because she thought that's what he wanted. Everyone else also acknowledges that Kyrie is smart and nearly every Kyrie/Rudolf plan is confirmed to have been her idea.
So I think we need to look at the motive for her, because it seems like she can convince Rudolf of things if she needs to and the idea will generally originate from her. Which isn't to say Rudolf even actually has to be involved, but if he is, it's probably because of her direction rather than the other way around.
__________________
|
2012-11-04, 03:57 | Link #31090 | |||
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
|
Quote:
Quote:
Problem for this development is why she'd kill Rudolf then. Even in her "worst possible incarnation" in the TP of EP7 she wouldn't have done that. Guess we can assume he didn't go along with the murders after all? Setting aside that Kyrietrice is not an intended solution anyway of course. Quote:
Let's assume she actually tried to influence the afterworld in some way or fashion relating to the incident she might've known something about/tried to start herself: It's not like she could've predicted how the letters would affect anything really, if they're even found. Maybe no mystery movement would be created, maybe someone would solve it the moment he/she lays eyes upon them, maybe somebody just considers it toilet paper, maybe everyone except her will he considered a possible culprit and goats start gnawing away at the illusion of a happy family causing Ange unbelieveable pain, etc. So even if she knew that a mass murder is about to happen it's hard to imagine how she tried to use the letters for her's or anyone's benefit. Heck, if we take the last example it might be the easiest to assume she did it out of anger towards Ange for leaving their little witch-society - and that's pretty harsh for something as little as that. Better to assume they had no 'logical' goal in the first place I think (at least I can't find one). |
|||
2012-11-04, 04:29 | Link #31091 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
|
Quote:
|
|
2012-11-04, 05:44 | Link #31092 | ||
Goat
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Gnawing away at Rokkenjima
|
Quote:
So using Kinzo as the extra body doesn't work unless he was murdered, and murdered inside the chapel by a culprit who was also inside the chapel. And since Kinzo is already dead at the starting time for all games! his murder would have had to taken place on an earlier date. Of course, depending on interpretation, this is all technically possible, in much the same way a George family solution was possible in Bern's game in EP8. But still, the idea that Kinzo was actually murdered originally is interesting. The timing of his death in Yasu's story always did seem contrived. Quote:
Just realized that that's probably a hidden double meaning in the title Our Confessions... Anyway, from the perspective of Ikuko=Yasu and post-incident authorship, the bottle stories could simply be an extravagant way for Ikuko (Yasu) to write to Touya (Battler) anonymously. ------------------------------------------------- So, I was thinking I would like to open a discussion on Our Confessions. Namely, what is it? Does such a story exist in Prime in the first place (even if unfound/unreleased)? If so, when was it written? Based on the meta-notes, which refer to the Siestas and Gaap, it was conceived at least after Banquet and probably Alliance. Assuming the meta-narrative follows the same timeline as Prime, that makes it impossible to be a genuine authored-pre-incident bottle-story. Yet it was thematically presented as such. Then there's Dlanor's role. What does it mean for Dlanor to release the incomplete manuscript after Beatrice's death? Who, or what mechanism is Dlanor representing here? |
||
2012-11-04, 07:26 | Link #31093 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2011
|
Quote:
But anyway, wouldn't the main problem with Kinzo being used as a corpse in the chapel be that he looks nothing like Kyrie anyway? I mean, there's a Knox rule against characters being disguised as other characters without clues. Regarding Our Confessions, I'd have to go back and check over the parts that reference the Siestas and Gaap, but Yasu and Maria DID originally invent those characters, so I don't think it's beyond the realm of possibility that she could have used them in other message bottle stories that were never found. But I think the whole dynamic between Dlanor and Beatrice is more of a metaphor for Ryukishi's own decision to release the story, rather than a representation of something in-universe. That is, Ryukishi was originally not going to release any more hints and accept the fact that some people would never accept the solution, but he changed his mind and released Our Confession out of his desire for more people to come to the truth. That's how I see it, anyway. |
|
2012-11-04, 07:51 | Link #31094 | |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
|
Quote:
Of course, the "death-makeup" is a shitty excuse for anything buuuut at least we're aware of it. Kinzo's remains would just sit wherever they are until someone decides to get rid of them. Regarding the visit that George and pals give them later (since Kyrie would need to go off and do her thing): highly unreliable scene to begin with and Kinzo could now take Kyrie's place, taking advantage of the darkness Did we twist the story enough? |
|
2012-11-04, 08:35 | Link #31096 |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
|
Actually the red when the six were killed in the chapel, the culprit was inside the chapel! is really a bane for this line of thought.
Okay, maybe we can twist semantics in a way that makes Yasu "the reason" for Kinzo's death as portrayed in EP7, the "culprit", but why did he die in the chapel then? Did he ask to be brought there in his dying moments? That's kind of stretching it, there are no hints. If anything we could say that Kinzo might think that a chapel, especially the one he build for himself and Beatrice, is a fitting place for his end. After all, he has finally reunited with Beatrice - therefore he can walk through the chapel-doors together with her. Setting aside that Kyrie definitely wouldn't be there, so we'd need to assume that "the culprit" refers to the culprits of their respective "crime" (in quotationmarks for Yasu); therefore it'd refer to both Yasu AND Kyrie... again, this is stretching it. But considering the basis of this theory, that Shkanon, Yasu's self-insert, is taking the blame for a crime she didn't even commit in those stories (of course only in relation to this theory), it'd be fitting to call her just a "culprit" (mind the quotationmarks), while Kyrie, the one she is supposedly covering for Battler's and Ange's peace of mind, is a culprit (mind the lack of quotationmarks) - both of them could be seen as one. This kinda WMG-ed out of control. Completely. Last edited by qno2; 2012-11-04 at 08:51. |
2012-11-04, 09:43 | Link #31097 |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
|
Well really the only way to get Kyrie out of the chapel is to say that someone else was dead in her place. This is the only way to get really anyone out of the chapel. Going through EP2's red truth that mention's people by name we get.
This morning, Rosa definitely took an envelope out of Maria's handbag, and thereby obtained the genuine key to the chapel The letter that I handed over to Maria and the one Rosa opened are the same thing Kanon was killed in this room No one exists in this room except all of you. 'All of you' refers to Battler, George, Maria, Rosa, Genji, Gohda, and Shannon When Jessica's corpse was discovered, only Battler, George, Maria, Rosa, Genji, Gohda, Shannon, Kumasawa, and Nanjo were in Jessica's room [Whoops, the corpse of] Jessica is also included Natsuhi's own key was in George's pocket, and the inside of the room was closed off Only the five master keys were left, and 'Rosa' was holding all of them There are a few more red Statments with Rosa's name in EP4 but they aren't too significant. So everyone's name was mentioned meaning the only way to get Kyrie out of the room is the same she inherited a name. I actually remember Battler using this argument with Kanon. So perhaps when you disguise as someone you inherit their name. (Would definitely make Shkanon nicer. Like every time Yasu dressed up as Kanon/Shannon she inherited their names rather than switching personalities). In this instance Rosa = Kyrie is possible. Someone should look through EP2 and see if their are any clues to Kyrie = Rosa. Last edited by Valkama; 2012-11-04 at 10:08. |
2012-11-04, 09:52 | Link #31098 | ||
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
|
Quote:
Quote:
Why can't she get out though (geniune question, been a while for me since I read EP2)? Apparently, if we want to take any hints from the magic scene of George & pals, it seems to be possible to unlock the door from inside. If in doubt, bring some strange mechanisms from the shed. In any case, is there any red that seals "those in the chapel" that I've forgotten? |
||
2012-11-04, 10:07 | Link #31099 | |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
|
Quote:
|
|
2012-11-04, 10:59 | Link #31100 | |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
|
Which is why we're discussing the possibility that Kinzo was "killed" ( = died because of the actions of someone else) back then inside the chapel, which actually isn't entirely without hints: wasn't it said that the chapel exists so Kinzo could walk through the door together with Beato? It has a certain "beauty" to it if he did it with Beato the third, just to die in there. Both a "wedding" and a funeral. Of course, in its essence this is another semantic cheat, I'm not saying that it is a good solution. In fact it seems kinda impossible to get Kyrie out of there without some rather outlandish ideas.
Therefore we'd have our sixth victim, Kyrie would be alive, and not in hiding because everybody saw her (another semantic cheat). The approach of inheriting a name was actually cut down anyway, wasn't it? Quote:
Nonserious approach: Maybe "Kanon" is the 'name' of the clothes, then you could switch to being Kanon via dressing up. Gives brands a whole new meaning, if you wear, say, Calvin Klein you ARE Calvin Klein. Deep statements about the nature of "you are what you wear", thank you Ryukishi. What was the name of Rosa's brand again? Clearly we have found x, an unknown label! ... okay, enough joking around, sorry. (warning, wild mass guessing incoming) They didn't use it on Kinzo though so it might be possible to use it on him... as in, becoming the head. Which might explain why Kinzo was so active (considering he's dead) in that episode... maybe one of the six took on his name, gained the position of the head (in that case... the gold has been found after all, hints exist). So Kyrie did indeed "die" (dealing with the issue that the six had been clearly specified), and became Kinzo. Which would also deal with all the issues we'd have with, you know, the servants and setting up the banquet. ... ... This is getting silly. Blasted red. I apologize. Last edited by qno2; 2012-11-04 at 11:19. |
|
|
|