Rate That Signature!

[Klashikari]

^ yes, She is Tear Grants, one of the main characters of Tales of Abyss

darkjester : the BG seem rather... weird, and i feel the Transmutation Sigil is kinda... unnatural here, more like a placeholder :x
the blending is however very smooth here, and the choice of colors, despite a bit surprising for ed, is nice.
7/10

bigdave : errr...Yoko is not cut properly, there are leftovers and it is jagged :x
also, i think her blending too dull, she isn't fitting the BG ~~
i guess the problem would also be the BG itself : kinda random ant not really giving a mood for her.
6/10

Cyz : it is a shame that the quality of the stock is really the top...
also, there is some problem with the edge (especially her hair)
finally, i think a bigger zoom on her eyes would have worked better.
that said, again, another improvement.
8/10

Sephi : well, the colors are really dull... it lacks of intensity and contrast
the bottom right "interface" thing looks really out of character too me (much more fitting a "tech" sig that this).
i think a sunny setup, with a wind brush can dramatically change the mood and quality here
7/10

[darkjester]

@bigdave: ....... /slap!... rofl, some advice i like, & some i don't... hehe, i tried your advice with the circle when
i was making the sig, & trust me, it looked horrible... as for my name, i liked the placement, i wanted it
small & out of the way...

bigdave: the bg, even though creative seems a bit too cluttered, the render is either of poor quality or
poorly cut & blended, & the lighting is a bit off imo... still as i said in yo thread its got flair... 7/10
Deathkillz: hmmm, not one of yo best sigs... the bg has something left to be said, the two cut images seem
to be just floating around, and again the lighting seems a bit off... still, not bad... 7.1/10

k thxs...

previous sig...

Spoiler for Sig Rated:

this is the sig u all have been rating...

[KeiKei-chan]

CrowKenobi : Konata Izumi ??? I don't think the background colour really suits Izumi ... 84%

Lordshin : I like the effects !!! 92%

Spectacular_Insanity : Not bad ! 86%

Sliver Dragon : A bit too bright ... 83%

Darkjester : Cool !!! 90%

Cyz : New one ? .... I like the colours ! 90%

[Mrs. Sagara]

Darkjester: I give you a [10!] because it is just so amazing! Great job with it!

KeiKei-chan: I give you a [9!] because it's just as amazing. But the double wording in such a small space doesn't go well, in my opinion. Great signature, overall though!

[bigdave]

hahah I tryed to fix some of the mistakes in my sig from all ur suggestions ^___^
here it is. *points down*

kei kei>> hahah SO kawaii!!! XD LOL 7.7/10
Dkz>> Oooo I like it!! the whole sig has a good flow to it. =D 8/10
Sagara>> Its plain and simple, I think sometimes the simple ones look nice too.^^ 7/10

edit: Of course I couldn't get rid of the bad rendering T___T
man I need to work harder to get better renders >,<

[Cyz]

@ Deathkillz: I thought it was Tifa at first but I guess not The BG and the image is shiny. 8/10

@ darkjester: Nice Ed pic. A little bright though 7/10

@ KeiKei-chan: A little plain and flat....but points for having my favorite Kanon character on it 7/10

@ Mrs. Sagara: Aha Pelly's work no? It would be nice if the image's dimension is a little bigger so you can see the pillow at the bottom. She looks a little creepy staring at me with those eyes 8/10

@ bigdave: Yoko! The quality of the pic isn't that great unfortunately. 7/10

-> New sig. Sachiko and Yumi from Maria-sama ga Miteru

[Mrs. Sagara]

lol cyz - Grr!

Well I love your signature, it's so adorable! It's just a little blurry.

Just a little

9/10 !

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by Mrs. Sagara

lol cyz - Grr!

Well I love your signature, it's so adorable! It's just a little blurry.

Just a little

9/10 !

Well, I did put a little blur in it. So the img quality is not to blame

@ bigdave: Nice Saber sig 7/10

[Drake]

Mrs. Sagara nice and simple i like the colours 8/10 =]

Deathkillz i like the backround and the image however the text is rather unclear and small but still nice 7/10

[Takeru]

Hooray! After a long week or so of finals testing I have returned!

Now to rate:
~Drake: beautiful 3D and editing job 8.9/10
~Cyz: very nice 8/10
~bigdave: -sigh- yet another poor soul that my firefox has attacked and refuses to show ?/10

as for mine, I was bored and decided to see what I could do with a render and a few filters.

[celcius]

Been a long time~

@Raiju32: Honestly. I can't really understand it anymore. Can barely see the guys face anymore (actually, his head looks like a large clump of black TBH). I think you're trying to make a submerged type effect, and browny points for that. Is that Kimi ga Nozomu Eien? 8/10
@Drake: The H in GHOSTS is a little bit hard to see since it was covered by the logo. 8.5/10
@Cyz: As I've said in your thread, the BG is a too blank and plain. 7/10
@Mrs.Sagara: :stare: 3_3 Love the eyes. 8/10
@bigdave: Maybe is just me, but the dark colors kinda don't match well with Saber's expression. 8.5/10

@me: Old sig. My new one is 100kB =.=

[Mrs. Sagara]

celcius I love YOUR sig!! xD

[[9/10!]]

[Crystal Requiem]

Dark Jester 9/10. Very nice coloring.
Kira Naruto 8/10. Funny.
guiltygearxt 8/10. Very nice graphics.
Cyz 5/10. Plain, could have done more with the coloring.
Deathkillz 8/10. Very nicely done, such great color flow. (You must have changed it just as I rated your last one )
Sephi 8/10. You darkened it quite nicely, the graphic is good as well.
Nurika Constar 2006 7/10. Nice lighting.
Diaboso 8/10. Very well done. The coloring and animation is nice.
Silver Dragon 7/10. Nice lighting and graphic work.
LordShin 6/10. A little fuzzy.
CrowKenobi 7/10. Cute.
Spectacular Insanity 7/10. Nice background to foreground shading/lighting.
bigdave 7/10. Good background coloring and graphics.
Klashikari 8/10. Good graphics, nice flow.
KeiKei-chan 5/10. Somewhat fuzzy.
Drake 9/10. Great color and darkening, good graphics.
Raiju32 10/10. Amazingly done. Flows so nicely, great graphic and color blending.
celcius 8/10. Cute and funny.
Mrs. Sagara 8/10. Good artwork.

I just did mine in microsoft paint, and used gimp for the text. Didn't feel like doing anything special.

[Sephi]

@Crystal Requiem
Looks nice. But mm the red border seems out of picture. Makes it look a bit odd. But that's just my opinion. 7.5/10

@Mrs. Sagara 7.5/10. Looks nice as a signature. But mmm don't like the pic to much.

@celcius 8/10 for the creativity :P Didn't notice it until i read the translation below and seeing the girl actually looking at the post.

@Raiju32 6.5/10 Think the filters didn't packed out to well. is that Tidus and Yuna ?

@Drake Oh wow, something not anime 8/10. Looks good overall

@Cyz 7.5/10. Don't know what but something seems missing. And mm perhaps try without blur?

Think i rated everyone else sig.

[Cyz]

@ Drake: Img is a little dark no? 5/10

@ Raiju32: It's a little dark too. 6/10

@ celcius: It's very...cartoonish 8/10

@ Crystal Requiem: Could use a different font style 7/10

@ Sephi: Love the BG color. It really suits her too. Too bad the left and right side are a tad too empty. 7/10

[darkjester]

Sephi: very nice... i love LUCY!... Nyu? 9/10
Cyz: cute.... a bit simple but it does the job... 7.3/10


k thxs


previous sig...

Spoiler for Sig Rated:

this is the sig u all have been rating...

[Deathkillz]

lets see...

Crystal Requiem ~ nice crop source other than that nothing much i can say...7.5/10

celcius ~ haha cute XD but its a shame your last one was too big :/ maybe if you pm me i can tweek it for you? :3 7.5/10

Raiju32 ~ hmm at first i thought it was just random patterns but now i see...Mitsuki 8/10

Sephi ~ yea i agree with cyz...maybe if you shorten the width it would look better...but on the whole i really like the focus and colour 8.5/10

[Cyz]

@ Deathkillz: Really really nice. The bluish BG really makes Suiginto look cool. Very icy btw 8/10

[Ayame_]

i like it, really simple, but clean 8/10

[Cyz]

@ Ayame: The black ribbons are a little off (though I'm not sure if it was part of the pic) Anyway,the img is really nice. Got 2 of my favorite Rozen Maiden there 8/10

-> New sig that I made. Too colorful ain't it? Anyway, that's Nagisa and Tamao-chan from Strawberry Panic. I really need to learn how to make a BG