2009-10-05, 09:59 | Link #2563 | ||||
Fanfic Writer
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||
2009-10-05, 10:10 | Link #2564 | |
Protecting the Throne
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Asia Tour
Age: 32
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2009-10-05, 10:27 | Link #2565 |
Fanfic Writer
|
Anyway evil_kenshin, I believe I proved my point. Many of us estimate Raki age to be different. I wonder if you really do see him as that young. I know flora and I think JB both esitmated him older than I have. But my point was that there is a justified reason why many of us "Raki haters" think that Raki is annoying. For me the biggest one is his irrational behavior, which would annoy me really no matter what age he is. And this Irrational behavior is not just in the Anime but can also be found in the manga, and people can get frustrated with the character from reading the Manga alone. The anime has a few more cases I could've used to demonstrate his irrational behavior, but this time I went strictly by the manga.
Dislike for the character is just an opinion, and as long as there is a valid reason for it, it is justified. |
2009-10-05, 11:28 | Link #2566 |
Just existing...
Join Date: Aug 2007
|
About Raki's age, we can only speculate. In the first chapter, he says he was playing outside when he heard the adults talking about the Claymores, which implies he can still be considered a child.
However, when he and Clare escaped from Ophelia, he was just eye level with her chest (as he was very aware of - lucky bastard ). Considering Clare's stats give her height at 170cm, he would have to be roughly 30cm shorter. Modern day height-for-age charts would estimate this to be normal for a boy between 10 and 11. Also, we have no idea how much time went between the two events (for instance, there is a 3 months gap between Ophelia's death and the events of the Witch's Maw, as stated by Rubel in chapter 41), but there seems to be a gap between the end of Slasher's arc and the Ophelia arc, and Raki's features seem more defined so he could have grown. In the 1st chapter, his face looks positively childish. But I doubt Clare and Raki had been traveling for more than a few months together. My personnal estimation would be that he is 12 at most when he separates from Clare, and 11 at the beginning of the series. Then again, we he meets Isley, he looks about 14... |
2009-10-05, 11:56 | Link #2567 |
Fanfic Writer
|
I know there is a yoma fight before the Ophelia incident, but to me the story has a greater impact if the time between the slasher arc and the endless gravestones arc is small, that after being sent to one suicide mission that clase is sent on another suicide mission, as if someone was trying to get rid of her.
|
2009-10-05, 15:45 | Link #2569 | |||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Australia
Age: 36
|
Quote:
Quote:
I doubt you have a real grasp of how 10 year old's work then, they wouldn't be willing to accept that. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
also "many of us" is more in the minority. |
|||||
2009-10-05, 16:02 | Link #2570 | |
Banned
Join Date: Jul 2009
|
I wonder where Yagi got raki from...
According to Wikipedia: Quote:
|
|
2009-10-05, 16:20 | Link #2572 | ||||||
Thread Hijacker
Join Date: May 2009
Location: In a hole, I just need to dig myself out
|
Sorry it took so long; can only write in between breaks and I've been busy busy busy.
Concerning his age, I agree with Weird D that he is somewhere in the range of 10-14. If he is a teenager, I consider him just barely. Quote:
http://forums.animesuki.com/showthre...67#post2516567 I don't have the time right now. Look back, I talk about what happned with Elena and what he did was perfectly sane and normal(and to me, his actions were what he should have done). MisterJB adds his own above me in that page. Quote:
Then I honestly question you Gangsta. Because that's what I would do, and I can't see how you see that as irrational. If I can't help someone, I find a way to do it any way I can; damn how much stronger they are then me. If this woman is all I have left in the world, you honestly think I'm just gonna sit by and let her go into a coma again? you think anybody is gonna be all logical and cool-headed like the way you describe in a life-or-death situation against a monster like that, when their are scared out of their mind and only barely over 10 years old? Quote:
You make it sound like he did the right thing and that's somehow wrong, I just don't get it. Quote:
Your words would be more accurate if her body was, say, like it was after she killed Rigardo. Quote:
Quote:
The problem with arguing like this is that we can argue logics like this; because none of us are in this situation, none of us are going to be, and we can seperate fantasy from reality. Take what I said above about Raki leaving or staying: you say it was irrational to leave and disobey Claire, but you think someone in that situation, much less someone that young, is gonna think so logically like that, with full-awareness and assurance that his presence wasn't going to matter whatsoever in the long run, not to mention it was become of his disobedience that ended up saving her in the end? You call him saving Claire dumb luck, but like it or not, he saved her life. If he left, she would be dead. You see that as luck because you didn't like him still being there in the first place. I do becuase I can understand why he was still there and he ended up helping her like he wanted too. He just didn't know it would be in the way it ended up. I suppose what it boils down too is, our different thought-processes and views on things...but that shouldn't even be considered because we can't look at these situations he's in and picture ourselves in the same ones, with the fore-knowledge we have of everything, our general knowledge including everything we know about the Claymore world, and what may and may not happen, and our cool mature-selves, specifically mentally. Before we can argue what is rational or irrational about Raki's actions, we need to do more then just look at things from his point of view. We need to look at them as if we were in his place, at his age. Suddenly, most of his actions aren't irrational in the least. If we both do all this and you still disagree, then I guess what it all boils down too is our differences in personalities. As I said above, my own actions wouldn't be all that different from what Raki did. If that makes me irrational so be it, not many kids his age are to begin with. Last edited by Shiek927; 2009-10-06 at 11:25. |
||||||
2009-10-05, 17:14 | Link #2573 |
Banned
Join Date: Sep 2009
|
join the military and go fight in wars... and you'll know what it's kinda like to be a claymore.. or a human in the claymore world....
the thing is most of us are probably not soldiers and have no idea what the real ugly "world" (humanity) is like beyond our peaceful utopia neighborhoods. yet many of us criticizing the younger raki for his crying. at least he is actually living through it. we aren't even doing that. how dare we criticize him for crying when most of us (unless you or someone you knew been the victim of a murder-crime) don't even know what it is like to lose a mom, a dad, a sister, a brother to another. and not just killed (which is gruesome enough), but eaten in front of you.... if the claymore manga was real..... 6-7 billion humans would probably be having heart attacks.... unable to even cope with the nightmare they be living in.... |
2009-10-06, 03:06 | Link #2574 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Cracow
Age: 46
|
Most probably Raki is a strange translation of word "lucky". Yagi in Claymore is using mostly english and french names and english word as names in japanese pronunciation, which was later retranslated into english. For example Rubul is not Rubul but Louvre.
As of Raki look and character - many of Claymore characters are expy of characters form Yagi first large work - Angel Densetsu. Raki is an expy of Leo Halford, who was, if I'm remember correctly - 12 years old.
__________________
|
2009-10-06, 10:05 | Link #2578 | |
Thread Hijacker
Join Date: May 2009
Location: In a hole, I just need to dig myself out
|
Quote:
Assuming Alicia joins with Riful and they remain their own faction, the Ghosts don't have time to play around; they must get rid of the Organization to focus on bigger things. Raki will probably become their last defense, not like they have anything else anymore. |
|
2009-10-06, 11:24 | Link #2579 |
Angriest Angel
Join Date: Nov 2007
|
This would be indeed a bitter fate for raki.
Becoming the obedient plaything of the org's researchers. This would describe his life indeed as a "bullet with butterfly wings" , he who allways wanted to become usefull to clare. Somehow this reminds me at the resident evil film in which mila/alice has to fight against her friend which became the "nemesis" tyrant.
__________________
|
2009-10-06, 12:58 | Link #2580 | |||||
Fanfic Writer
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||||
|
|