AnimeSuki Forums

JokerD · 2004-03-30, 00:02

Having seen both the anime and the manga (both translated by Lililicious and A-Source, thanks guys) I have this question:
Which one is a more accurate representation of the novels? There seem to be noted differences between the two.
Thanks in advance

laurore31 · 2004-03-30, 01:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by JokerD

Having seen both the anime and the manga (both translated by Lililicious and A-Source, thanks guys) I have this question:
Which one is a more accurate representation of the novels? There seem to be noted differences between the two.
Thanks in advance

the anime !

because the manga is just more fun.

pkgirl163 · 2004-03-30, 09:00

Quote:

Originally Posted by JokerD

Having seen both the anime and the manga (both translated by Lililicious and A-Source, thanks guys) I have this question:
Which one is a more accurate representation of the novels? There seem to be noted differences between the two.
Thanks in advance

From what I've read so far it would be the manga. The anime seems to skip over a lot.

^PaNdA · 2004-04-01, 12:20

the manga can express more from the novel than anime because anime has a limited time/room to tell the story while the manga is practically endless... unless it sucks or something and gets cancelled....

2004-03-30, 00:02	Link #1
JokerD Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2003	Manga? Anime? Having seen both the anime and the manga (both translated by Lililicious and A-Source, thanks guys) I have this question: Which one is a more accurate representation of the novels? There seem to be noted differences between the two. Thanks in advance

2004-04-01, 12:20	Link #4
^PaNdA I hate you n_n Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: land of hippies	the manga can express more from the novel than anime because anime has a limited time/room to tell the story while the manga is practically endless... unless it sucks or something and gets cancelled....