AnimeSuki Forums

WTTrinity · 2004-10-20, 04:20

I wonder if Marimite has caused an upsurge in Catholic school entry applications the way Hikaru no Go (supposedly) caused an upturn in the popularity of Go among kids. Obviously life in a real Catholic school would be a bit less romantic, but that's not necessarily enough to deter a fad.

It would have been pretty cool if they'd had a nice-looking nun and a couple of pretty girls doing Sunday school lessons or something like that after each episode the way HnG had these Go lessons with Yukari-sensei. But I guess that wouldn't be possible because proselytizing is viewed a bit differently...

Although they could have just been teaching peripheral trivia about Catholicism... But I guess this series might bring in the contingent that would get the church in trouble with the female side of things the same way they have been with the male side in recent times (if you know what I mean), so maybe they'd prefer not being associated with it

Actually, I wonder if the Catholic church or any other Christian group in Japan has made any comments at all about this show, positive or negative. I'm guessing they haven't. I'm pretty sure though that once this gets licensed in the US some religious group will try to find fault with the "sisterly love" thing going to far, etc. if they find out about it. Anything less would be un-American

(Chalk it up to my sleep deprivation if what I just wrote sounded weird or offensive. I think I'm unable to gauge that myself right now... Didn't mean to offend anyone, certainly.)

GundamZZ · 2004-10-20, 05:47

If Marimite becomes a hit, it's more likely to have increasing membership in sororities. I remember that Kyoto University had a mock Lillian souer meeting poster.

Anyway, here's the school tour for Lillian girl's school.
http://www.fuzzy2.com/marimite/20030105.html

**Keitaro** · 2004-10-20, 06:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by GundamZZ

If Marimite becomes a hit, it's more likely to have increasing membership in sororities. I remember that Kyoto University had a mock Lillian souer meeting poster.

I suspect the shut down of Lillian girl's school's website is due to the show. Actully, I guess 2chaners maybe more guilty on that matter. Anyway, here's the school tour.
http://www.fuzzy2.com/marimite/20030105.html

So there’s actually a real Lillian girl’s school O_O. I thought this school was made up, interesting. Do they have the same kind of sourer system like in the novels and anime too?

**kj1980** · 2004-10-20, 07:32

No.

The area and the school is a place where the author modeled the details from. The place is the Musashino area of Tokyo - an area where a lot of manga authors, anime production studios, and industry related personnel and companies reside.

Not to make you disappointed, but there is no real "Lillian," nor a place with a soeur system. The real name of that school is "Musashino Joshi-Gakuin" (Musashino All-Girl's School).

HP for "Musashino Joshi-Gakuin": http://www.mj-net.ed.jp/

Proto · 2004-10-20, 10:06

Hmm... i remember some german member mentioning that there was a girl school she assisted too that had something similar to a soeur system... though she mentioned that no one really followed it ^^

GundamZZ · 2004-10-20, 11:30

Haha, even Deutsch people embrace yuri.

http://www.yuri-gakuin.ac.jp/high/high.htm
http://www.shirayuri.ac.jp/index.html
http://www.sendai-shirayuri.ac.jp/

ps. In case you wonder why the school is called white lily, white lily is the flower of Virgin Mary. Like white rose, white yuri(lily) stands for virginity and purity. Though, I doubt Sei is a virgin.

Sugu · 2004-10-24, 03:38

A number of American boarding schools has something similar to soeur system. Perhaps a small number, but then, they are not terribly common. In some cases they are called the oneesama's are called "old girls," and in a way act as a student peer version of the more common "advisor," although the girls I don't think choose these relationships for themselves which I suppose is an instrumental aspect of the system at Lillian, and so not all take advantage of the arrangement.

I was wondering if there was some kind of reason that the manga authors and animation companies commonly reside in this particular district of Tokyo, other than the relationship between the mangaka and production companies?

Also, GundamZZ, what are these links you sent?? I'm very interested yet do not know Japanese!! What is the relationship between them and Germany? I love looking at these different schools ^o^

7thMethuselah · 2004-10-24, 06:18

delete please I posted in the wrong thread

GundamZZ · 2004-10-24, 06:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sugu

Also, GundamZZ, what are these links you sent?? I'm very interested yet do not know Japanese!! What is the relationship between them and Germany? I love looking at these different schools ^o^

They are two subjects. Those places are Japanese schools named after white lily. The translation of Yuri Gakuin is Lily School. http://www.yuri-gakuin.ac.jp/high/ev....taiikusai.htm

Shirayuri College literately mean White Lilly College.
http://www.shirayuri.ac.jp/daigaku/in/index.html

Back to Germany subject, white lily reminds me about a story from Grimm Brothers' folktales. If I remember correctly, it also has something to do with Virgin Mary.

LucifersGirl · 2004-11-28, 12:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProtoMan

Hmm... i remember some german member mentioning that there was a girl school she assisted too that had something similar to a soeur system... though she mentioned that no one really followed it ^^

Soeur system is kinda an Asian thing I guess, although it isn't required, it's pretty common. I have them in Junior-High, High School and in College. The system is pretty similar to what you see in the show, my grande soeur help me with school matter (lending/giving her used text book, tuitoring when can, etc.) Social matters and Personal ones (Depended on how close you are). The different is you don't usually get to choose, since it'll be unfair to less popular underclassmate that might not get pick or get pick last. Mine was assigned according to the "Student Code", you can trade, if all agree, but that rarely happen since it could hurt the feeling of who you traded. There're some other school/class I know that use the same system as the show; you choose you own soeur, but that isn't common. Also since I'm in co-ed your soeur might not be same gender, although it usually is.

The whole idolizing upperclassmate girls or having "(Unofficial) Fan club" is also common especially in Girls school, but not for guys.

gizmogal · 2006-09-24, 10:01

I attend a Sacred Heart school (all girls, catholic) and in Upper School, we have a "big sister, little sister" system. The juniors all pick a freshman to be 'sister' with... nothing big comes of it, though, unlike in the anime! :3

2004-10-20, 04:20	Link #1
WTTrinity Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2004	Marimite as a recruitment tool I wonder if Marimite has caused an upsurge in Catholic school entry applications the way Hikaru no Go (supposedly) caused an upturn in the popularity of Go among kids. Obviously life in a real Catholic school would be a bit less romantic, but that's not necessarily enough to deter a fad. It would have been pretty cool if they'd had a nice-looking nun and a couple of pretty girls doing Sunday school lessons or something like that after each episode the way HnG had these Go lessons with Yukari-sensei. But I guess that wouldn't be possible because proselytizing is viewed a bit differently... Although they could have just been teaching peripheral trivia about Catholicism... But I guess this series might bring in the contingent that would get the church in trouble with the female side of things the same way they have been with the male side in recent times (if you know what I mean), so maybe they'd prefer not being associated with it Actually, I wonder if the Catholic church or any other Christian group in Japan has made any comments at all about this show, positive or negative. I'm guessing they haven't. I'm pretty sure though that once this gets licensed in the US some religious group will try to find fault with the "sisterly love" thing going to far, etc. if they find out about it. Anything less would be un-American (Chalk it up to my sleep deprivation if what I just wrote sounded weird or offensive. I think I'm unable to gauge that myself right now... Didn't mean to offend anyone, certainly.) Last edited by WTTrinity; 2004-10-20 at 04:33.

2004-10-20, 05:47	Link #2
GundamZZ 美人薄命 Join Date: Oct 2004	If Marimite becomes a hit, it's more likely to have increasing membership in sororities. I remember that Kyoto University had a mock Lillian souer meeting poster. Anyway, here's the school tour for Lillian girl's school. http://www.fuzzy2.com/marimite/20030105.html Last edited by GundamZZ; 2004-10-20 at 06:05.

2004-10-20, 07:32	Link #4
kj1980 kaii~...kana? kana? Moderator Join Date: Nov 2003 Age: 28	No. The area and the school is a place where the author modeled the details from. The place is the Musashino area of Tokyo - an area where a lot of manga authors, anime production studios, and industry related personnel and companies reside. Not to make you disappointed, but there is no real "Lillian," nor a place with a soeur system. The real name of that school is "Musashino Joshi-Gakuin" (Musashino All-Girl's School). HP for "Musashino Joshi-Gakuin": http://www.mj-net.ed.jp/ Last edited by kj1980; 2004-10-20 at 08:54.

2004-10-20, 11:30	Link #6
GundamZZ 美人薄命 Join Date: Oct 2004	Haha, even Deutsch people embrace yuri. http://www.yuri-gakuin.ac.jp/high/high.htm http://www.shirayuri.ac.jp/index.html http://www.sendai-shirayuri.ac.jp/ ps. In case you wonder why the school is called white lily, white lily is the flower of Virgin Mary. Like white rose, white yuri(lily) stands for virginity and purity. Though, I doubt Sei is a virgin. Last edited by GundamZZ; 2004-10-20 at 20:48.

2004-10-24, 06:18	Link #8
7thMethuselah Sleeping Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Leuven, Vlaanderen, Europa Age: 33	delete please I posted in the wrong thread __________________

2004-10-20, 10:06	Link #5
Proto Knowledge is the solution Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: U. of Wisconsin, Previously in Mexico City. Age: 25	Hmm... i remember some german member mentioning that there was a girl school she assisted too that had something similar to a soeur system... though she mentioned that no one really followed it ^^

2004-10-24, 03:38	Link #7
Sugu Suguho, really Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Amherst, New York Age: 24	A number of American boarding schools has something similar to soeur system. Perhaps a small number, but then, they are not terribly common. In some cases they are called the oneesama's are called "old girls," and in a way act as a student peer version of the more common "advisor," although the girls I don't think choose these relationships for themselves which I suppose is an instrumental aspect of the system at Lillian, and so not all take advantage of the arrangement. I was wondering if there was some kind of reason that the manga authors and animation companies commonly reside in this particular district of Tokyo, other than the relationship between the mangaka and production companies? Also, GundamZZ, what are these links you sent?? I'm very interested yet do not know Japanese!! What is the relationship between them and Germany? I love looking at these different schools ^o^

2006-09-24, 10:01	Link #11
gizmogal Junior Member Join Date: Sep 2006	I attend a Sacred Heart school (all girls, catholic) and in Upper School, we have a "big sister, little sister" system. The juniors all pick a freshman to be 'sister' with... nothing big comes of it, though, unlike in the anime! :3