Rate That Avatar!

[ganbaru]

RadiantBeam 8,6/10 not bad
Kuroi Hadou 8.8/10 great artwork
MetalCookie 8,7/10 nice
JRendell 8,6/10 interesting

[delorean2200]

halad: 9/10 nice.
MetalCookie: 9.3/10 nice as well.
Kuroi Hadou: 9/10 interesting Fate fan art.
RB: 10/10 wow love it.
JRendell: 9/10 nice ^^.
Ganbaru: 9.5/10 interesting.

[delirium]

delorian2200: I don't relly like it. 2/10
ganbaru: I think it would look nicer if the curve was facing your posts. 5/10
JRendell: There isn't anything I don't like about yours. 10/10

[Haladflire65]

JR: A bit bright. 8.7/10
ganbaru: The diagonals look a bit jagged, 8.6/10
delorean: lol. 8.6/10

[delirium]

Originally Posted by Haladflire65

JR: A bit bright. 8.7/10
ganbaru: The diagonals look a bit jagged, 8.6/10
delorean: lol. 8.6/10

Haladflire65: 1/10(-9 because I'm not really seeing anything new with your avatar. You can't say much work is going into it. You crop the picture to 100x100 with an obvious focus on the face, select all, stroke the border with white to 3 pixels, stroke it with black to 2 pixels. You made it sound like you were awesome and more experienced than me, so what's with the lack of experimentation? Are you a one-trick pony?)(+1 because the quality isn't poor).
ganbaru: 8/10: I really like this! The angles on the top and bottom are jagged though, so that's why you get -2.

[delorean2200]

@delirium: Lets say you are right and he didn't worked much on the image, this thread is about rating how good an avatar is regardless how much you worked on it (same is true for the sig one)... i would rather have a cropped one with good quality (which as an image does deserve more since regardless if the person who uses it put effort or not, because even if it isn't the user someone did actually put some effort into making/taking that shoot) then an avatar which has a lower quality Psy Locke strapped on a BG without any proper blending... Still this looks more like a grudge imho, since you rated someone else which did less effort with quite an honorable rating.

ganbaru: 8.6/10 nice concept but dunno the shape just doesn't feel right and its a bit dark.

[ganbaru]

Delorean2200 8,4/10 not bad

@ delirium. Just to say than effort don't always show on the end result. My avatar are often just a ''less than 10 minute'' work. The only originality than I can claim it the shape and sometime the choice of focus.

[hinakatbklyn]

@ganbaru - Interesting shape. 8.5/10
@delorean2200 - Cute character. 8.5/10
@Kuroi Hadou - Almost didn't recognize Fate. Nice. 8.5/10
@JRendell - Very cute expression. Nice effects and focus. 9.2/10
@RadiantBeam - Looking good. 8.7/10

[RadiantBeam]

@Ganbaru: Very pretty, interesting new shape. 10/10
@Delorean2200: Ha, cute. 9.5/10
@JRendell: Aww. 9.5/10

[kya-chan]

Radiant: Nice focus 9.6/10

[RadiantBeam]

@Kya-chan: Loop is kind of slow, but it's cute. 9.5/10

[ganbaru]

kya-chan 8,3/10 a bit slow
RadiantBeam 8,6/10 good focus

[Haladflire65]

kya-chan: Agreeing w/ everybody, 8.6/10
Beamers: Nice one 8.7/10

[hinakatbklyn]

@kya-chan - Nice looking gif. 8.8/10
@RadiantBeam - Seconded nice one. 8.8/10

[Konakaga]

RadiantBeam : Very cute and good focus and image 9.2/10
hinakatbklyn : Fairly cute too, so 9.0/10

[Kuroi Hadou]

Konakaga: 8.5/10: Cute, but I don't much like that border style.

[delorean2200]

hinakatbklyn: 9.5/10 cute
Konaga: nice cute gif 10/10

To whoever left this comment on my previous post in this thread:

Wow you really are rude .. Not all avatars are supposed to be something you '' work on '' .. Hell, not all even are capable of image editing. Sometimes you just want a simple crop of space without all special effects and whatever ..

You totally misunderstood what i was saying there, my message their was quite the opposite of what you thought (in fact i was saying pretty much the same thing as you), sorry for resorting to this but since you didn't sign i had no other way of replying and i wanted to clear the misunderstanding... if you still don't properly understand what i was saying i can explain it more in detail in a pm if you want, but for that i gotta know who am i talking to though...

[Yorg]

Kuroi Hadou 8.8/10 cute. even tho i dont know what anime she is from.
delorean2200 8.6/10 funny.

As for delorean2200 post up top it seems that person has been taking care of.so its all good.

[synaesthetic]

@Konakaga: Cute icon, love the loop! 10/10
@Yorg: ugh, melting, Kirino is too cute... 9/10

[ganbaru]

Konagata 8,9/10 good gif
Yorg 8,8/10 nice