Rate That Signature!

[Lord Uiruu]

rikimtasu: okay.. 8/10

[James Lame]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

James Lame 8.7/10 good looking , may I ask where it came from?

I'm assuming your speaking about the render?
I got it over at planet renders, here ya go [ http://planetrenders.net/renders/dis...php?pos=-20436 ]

[ganbaru]

Christine247 8.4/10 pretty girl, but there is something lacking.

[Rikimtasu]

@James Lame 9.3/10
@Lord Uiruu 9/10
@Christine247 7.9/10

New stuff i made today...kind of missing something,any good suggestion?

EDIT:Not really final edit,but i just tweaked the sprite part three time..

Another one with background.The one with BG is better or the one wihout the BG?

[christine_cute]

i made some changes though^^

[Rikimtasu]

@Christine247 8/10 Look a bit better,may be use some other colour?

[grylsyjaeger]

Rikimtasu: The one with the background is better but it still feels lacking. Maybe a border. And I don't know, something about the figure on the far right seems out of place.

Christine247: Interesting image but IMO the border really needs to be a different colour, mate. 8.5/10

[Hs Vi Germania]

Originally Posted by Rikimtasu

@James Lame 9.3/10
@Lord Uiruu 9/10
@Christine247 7.9/10

New stuff i made today...kind of missing something,any good suggestion?

EDIT:Not really final edit,but i just tweaked the sprite part three time..

Another one with background.The one with BG is better or the one wihout the BG?

I would prefer the one with background, but both are not really what I like.
Sorry

[ganbaru]

Rikimtasuposted ones 7.7/10 I prefer the one with the sky backgroung. But I suggedt to find a other render for remplacing the one at the right of the sig.
Christine247 8,6/10 better but there's still room to improvement.

[Sinfully Naomi]

I prefer the one with the sky background as well, but I still think soemthing is missing from it...

Oooooh, ganbaru, nice new one. 9/10~ very nice. :3

[Hs Vi Germania]

ganbaru: very very very very ~~ very nice new one Just the text is nearly unreadable. It is a pity 9/10

[TheZap]

Rikimtasu: Looks just like 2 renders and a Bg
If you made the render, 7/10
if you didnt, 4/10

[Nemu]

Sinfully Naomi: 10/10 Rika! It is a really cool signature. ^_^
TheZap: 8/10 It is really colorful!
ganbaru: 8/10, not sure what to say about it but it is nice.

[Mon Cheri]

Zappy: Me like! So nice and colorful 8/10
Popsicle: Nice, but render is a bit small and it's a bit plain... 7/10
ganbaru: The signature looks good, but you have to change the color of the text and border! The current one is almost unreadable and looks very bad (sorry). 5/10. Change da text and that sig will rule!

[Hey Boss!]

Malin-Good 8/10
Sinfully Naomi-I LIKE!!10/10
Popsicle-Hmm... 7.8/10

[escimo]

ganbaru - 6/10 - Color of the text doesn't work at all. Unreadable. Otherwise quite nice.
Sinfully Naomi - 6.5/10 - Good colors, not so good border and going a bit overboard with outer glows.
TheZap - 0/10(7/10) - Over the size limit. Feels a bit messy. Lacks focus. Do like the colorfulness though.
Popsicle -7/10 - Don't really like the double render and as it's quite large it seems a bit empty. Would probably work better with the current elements if it was quite a bit narrower.
Malin - 9/10 - Good solid vector sig, well blended and good colors. Maybe a bit generic though.
Hey Boss! - 5/10 - Inverted colors = No. Never really works.

[Lord Uiruu]

escimo: 7/10

[Rikimtasu]

Originally Posted by TheZap

Rikimtasu: Looks just like 2 renders and a Bg
If you made the render, 7/10
if you didnt, 4/10

I did the render myself...

Originally Posted by Sinfully Naomi

I prefer the one with the sky background as well, but I still think soemthing is missing from it...

Thank for suggestion...well,i still thinking what is the missing thing thought.

Originally Posted by ganbaru

Rikimtasuposted ones 7.7/10 I prefer the one with the sky backgroung. But I suggedt to find a other render for remplacing the one at the right of the sig.

I did have you said^^

Originally Posted by fallschirmjager

Rikimtasu: The one with the background is better but it still feels lacking. Maybe a border. And I don't know, something about the figure on the far right seems out of place.

Added border and fixed a bit on my old ver of signature.

So...there is two choice for me now:

V4.1:


V5:



Which one is better right now?

@escimo 9.3/10
@Hey Boss! 7.5/10 I not into the reverse colour stuff...
@Malin 9.5/10
@Popsicle 8.7/10 May be somemore blood and change it to a mad Rena? LOL
@TheZap 7.9/10
@ganbaru 9.3/10
@Sinfully Naomi 9.1/10

Really,i'm being a nice guy recently...

[ganbaru]

TheZap 8/10 look interesting but overweight
malin 8.9/10 Don't knoe those kagamine sisters bit it look good.
hey Boss! 7.2/10 should have stay with the true color.
Lord Uiruu 8.2/10 a singular cloud
@Rikimtasu V4.1 is better , the new render seem odd to me .

Thank for the C&C I will correct my sig soon.

[Haruyan]

@ganbaru - 7/10 - Text is unreadable because of the colors.
@Rikimtasu - 5/10 - The image on the right just doesn't fit with the image on the left. But if I have to choose, V.4.1
@Lord Uiruu - 8.7/10 - A bit too simple, too much open space.
@escimo - 9.8/10 - Very nice, I like the simplicity
@Hey Boss - 8/10 - Would've preferred the original colors
@Malin - 9.8/10 - Nice and clean