Rate That Signature!

[philhalo66]

5/10 kinda lame

[ganbaru]

philhalo66 8,5/10 the limit is 48,8kb

[philhalo66]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

philhalo66 8,5/10 the limit is 48,8kb

its 20KB now

[Godlike1889]

philhalo66: 5/10...Text isn't readable, can't see a border, render is too bright (around the face) and it looks stretched.
Rennir: 9/10...awesome I already gave you a full review
ganbaru: 8/10...I like the overall signature, but the renders are a little bit too dark for me.
Haladflire65: 9/10...Great effects Halad!
Kagayaki 8,5/10...Nice effects o_o

[SOGESNAKE]

Godlike1889: 9.5/10 - It's just so.... colorful~

[delirium]

Godlike1889: 10/10 It's really gorgeous, there is no way to deny it is awesome.
philhalo66: 8/10 for a good attempt. The flaws are obvious, but it's not as though we should expect better from you, therefore you get the rating that you did. I hope you keep working on your signatures and such and improving them with each iteration. I can see what that signature will look like when you improve and I've gotta tell you it will be pretty!

[Godlike1889]

delirium: 7/10...The overall signature is nice. The left side does look a little bit empty. Her left hand (for us: Right hand ) is too bright. To be honest: I don't like the text, you should change that IMO.

[ganbaru]

delirium 8.5/10 as Godlike1889 said, it a bit empty and the text could use some work

[delorean2200]

Godlike1889: 10/10 simply nicely done and good quality.

[Dist]

ganbaru : I like this more than your previous works. Your usual style seems to be uhh .. not sure what it's called but there's the background, and the character, and then there's white around the character .. It's a lil repetitive over time. However, I'm not sure what actual work has gone to this signature as it looks like a crop and added text. With that said, 6/10 for now. ++ points for the text since it's in japanese and doesn't take as much space as texts usually do with your signatures.

[delorean2200]

Dist: 10/10 i simply love it <3.

[delirium]

Dist: 8/10 The flaw with your previous signature is now gone from my sight. It doesn't look so bad now! I'm glad Patchy finally made a better one for you.
delorean2200: 4/10 I appreciate Gundam as much as the next person, but the text you're using for your name, along with the gradiant overlay & stroke diminish it greatly. I mean no offense, but I can do the same thing! Let me tell you how. Select the text tool > enter text > right click on text layer > select blending options > select 3 pixel outside white stroke > go to gradient over lay > select red & black gradiant > press okay > go to file > save as. What I'm trying to say is that it seems very lazy. I expect to get some amount of negative reputation for this, but it must be said!

[JRendell]

delorean: Nice Gundam sig. I like the vector style you went for; it looks great! 8/10
delirium: It's ok, but the text is more of a focal that the render, which is a problem. That's a ghastly shade of yellow/brown too 6.5/10

[Kagayaki]

delorean: I love the purple and that pattern in the background. 8.6/10
delirium: Agree with JRendell about the text. I like the pose of the render and the "V" shape of the fire. 8/10
JRendell: D'awww. 8.8/10

[ganbaru]

Dist 8,8/10 another great work from Patchy
delorean2200 8,4/10 not bed
delirium 8,4/10 from experience, text haven't to be that big
JRendell 8,5/10 nice

@ Dist about my signature, I put more modification on the original material than the signature itself, which is also the case with scenery signature

[Dist]

Originally Posted by delirium

Dist: 8/10 The flaw with your previous signature is now gone from my sight. It doesn't look so bad now! I'm glad Patchy finally made a better one for you.

Would you mind going into detail as exactly how does this signature differ from the previous one so much ? The character is about at the center, we have text and some effects. Only this is much more colorful. But, there was a reason for the background which Wendy had and you'd know what it was if you'd watch Fairy Tail and knew who she is. Also .. Patchy made this to me before the Wendy one but I change my sig only once per month.

Kagayaki : Amazing BRS signature. I love the effects and especially the star .. I think someone criticized the star but again, if they had watched BRS they'd know the star has a significant meaning. The only flaw is that it feels a little empty on the right side. 9.5/10

[NakanoAzusa]

Dist: 9/10
delorean: 10/10 ( I love strike!!)
Kagayaki: 8/10 ( Nice BR*S)
Ganbaru: 10/10 (Hao....hanyuu is so cute~~~)

[Haladflire65]

Kagayaki: LOVE the text - nice modification! 9/10
Dist: It feels a bit busy and the text is a bit long, but nice work from Patchy overall. 8.7/10
Nakano: Not bad, 8.4/10

[delorean2200]

JRendell: 8.7/10 lol nice one.
Nakano: 8.6/10 lol again.

[delirium]

delorean2200: 6/10 The text is really that much better, but it's at a point now where we should ask if it even needs to be there. The Gundam SEED text is the focal point of it all next to the Gundam, and there your name is. Oh lord! I have an awesome idea for you. Get rid of the "Gundam (S)EED" text, enlarge the CAT-X105 STRIKE text and then put your name in that same area. It would look awesome.

Originally Posted by JRendell

delirium: It's ok, but the text is more of a focal that the render, which is a problem. That's a ghastly shade of yellow/brown too 6.5/10

Is my signature more or less Gastly now?