Originally Posted by Tempest35
But out of your list here, only Benkei actually comes close to fitting and her amputation was self-inflicted so she could get away. Simca, Rika, and Maya all got hurt because of their 'target man'.
The only reason I got on Rampak was the way they used the examples they gave to justifiy their logic. Most of the examples that were given were twisted and one-sided, saying that a injury instance done to them was a form of 'punishment' for not totally devoting themselves to a man, which is just a WRONG statement, especially in Benkei's case. Benkei was a fighter through and through - the statement that her injury was some punishment for not waiting on Yoshitsune hand and food like a 'good little woman' enrages me. It dishonors her to have what she went through to be summed up so contritely and as a fighter myself, it pisses me off.
A better topic/point would be: Why are so many of OG's girls so willing to be injured for the sake of the man that they like? Is it to provide a reason for the man to take it up to the next level and fight like the demon that they are? Or is it because OG likes drawing violence done to women?
^ A statement like that would have been much better for this thread instead of a random quote with a French twist and half-assed reference to 200 year old French novels.... That's the reason I called rampak a troll - you shouldn't half-ass a statement such as the one they put forward.
People don't just read manga you know,, a comment is based on what one 's knowledge and experience. I happened to know french and love reading , is that so wrong?
Yes what happened to Benkei is exactly my point. , she was strong then she got amputated. it doesn't matter whether it was self inflicted or inflicted by others. I didn't say Benkei did it for a man, she just an great woman
Have you seen the the chapter 338 pic? that exactly what it is not happening to Emily. I think you actually strengthening my point by saying that Emily weak / does not stand out.