AnimeSuki Forums

Register Forum Rules FAQ Members List Social Groups Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Go Back   AnimeSuki Forum > Anime Discussion > Older Series

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 2010-09-26, 06:04   Link #121
roriconfan
Banned
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Thessaloniki - Greece
Send a message via MSN to roriconfan
MY REVIEW

Consider this review an overall criticism in the entire franchise. Reading this one is like reading a review about all the seasons. And its more like a retrospective text; I talk about its overall importance in anime history and less about technicals. You have been warned.

Slayers began in mid 90’s as a slapstick comedy using a Medieval fantasy setting. It was an rpg parody of sorts, as it kept using several trademarks of the genre, ridiculed by various anachronisms and mockery through exaggeration. And yes, it worked fine for its time. The humor was very fitting to the setting and usually numerous gags would appear on the same episode. Plus, although its humor wasn’t really unique or special it was still the only one famous in this sort of setting at the time. There were others but none got this much fame or weren’t that funny to begin with. Also, The Record of Lodoss War was at its prime back then and this series felt as a parody of that series, so it had a close by relative work to make fun of.

The anime got 3 full seasons (original, Next, Try) and numerous movies and specials in a span of less than a decade. It was a huge marketing point and the producers did their best to milk it as best as possible. Eventually, they stopped making more and it appeared the franchise had ended its course. Yet many fans wanted another series, as the title was originally a light novel series and the three seasons hardly covered the entire story. After several years in hiatus, they eventually made a fourth season (Revolution), divided into two halves; a typical method these days. The name implied it would revolutionize the market and sell out because of the endless hoards of otakus storming the stores or something. Yet the welcoming was mediocre at best.

So what went wrong? The formula was definitely not at fault; it was done in the exact same way as in the 90’s and it wasn’t watered down or altered to the point you would think it’s a different series. So what’s the deal?

Well… that was actually the deal. It was identical as before. Nothing went forward or backward, besides the improvement on visuals. People got one of the same, when all those years of waiting made them think they would get something else. But it makes little sense if I don’t get into details.

First of all it’s the story. There is one; it’s not a storyless comedy (thank God) and does change its objectives every 12 episodes or so. And here is were the first brick wall popped up in the road towards Enjoyville. It is mostly fillers! Yes, it changes the objective every 12 episodes but that practically translates to 1 episode introduction of the new goal, 2 episodes of showdown and 9 episodes of random one-shot adventures in the middle of a vague area. Back in the 90’s people were far more tolerant of fillers, or stand-alones or whatever. But not anymore; now the average fan demands one of the following four three:
1) Continuous story telling
2) Gracious amounts of fan service, or
3) Deep immersion to the mood of the setting
4) All of the above in any ludicrous way we feel like it since we are ungrateful and never satisfied little bastards

And in all honesty, Slayers never had much of any of these f… three. The story is pretty simple and straight-forward, filled with random events to the most part. It never had eye-popping visuals and any erotic humor it ever had was pretty poor, while it never went for bijin looks or whatever. As for the setting itself, it was a generic Medieval world, with a vague map filled with random kingdoms and ancient ruins that never had any relation to one another. And now try to imagine pitting this next to later famous titles, like Full metal Alchemist Brotherhood (point 1), Queen’s Blade (point 2), or Mushishi (point 3) , or Pokemon (point 4) … just kidding.

The only saving grace the series was left with was the humor, which although of the same type and volume as before, it now feels outdated. Yes, even humor changes in tastes as years go by. The comedy it’s using feels by today’s standards weak and repetitive. Today’s fans prefer types like Sayonara Zetsubo, Bakemonogatari or Gintama. Slayers’ volume and density has no hope next to them. And let’s face it; it kept using the same gags again and again in all 4 seasons and movies and specials that can eventually tire anyone. I mean, half the jokes were always about Lina getting angry with her small breast, Gourry being totally ignorant, Amelia acting like a spaced-out superhero of justice, etc. It gets tiresome if something doesn’t change around a bit. And it does but after lots of episodes and never too much.

Speaking of change, the story is by far too weak, both in storytelling and actual premise. At first it looked like a great concept, as the universe of the series is actually four worlds held by pillars that were created by the Mother of Destruction, aka the Lord of Nightmares. Dragon Gods and Demons keep fighting in each one, for their dominance or destruction and there are some twists around. Yes, it looks mighty interesting but at the same time it happens in a totally random way and has no consistency whatsoever. I mean, in the first season they fight an arch-demon, while in the second his sub-leaders, who for some reason are harder to beat even when the heroes have acquired far more powerful spells and weapons. And as if that wasn’t enough, Revolution pretty much reuses the same story as in the first season, with only difference the addition of her never-seen-so-far sister and an irritating mascot animal. Ok, repetitive is one thing, rehash is another. Story gets a 3.

The characters are overall likable but never mature or change in any way. Lina can pretty much use her signature attack, the city-leveling Dragon Slave, every 5 minutes without any setback. A thing she does in any chance she gets, no matter how unimportant the reason may be. Yup, she overall causes more damage than the villains and that was a great joke … the first hundred times. Now it simply is tiresome. So is her small breast. Lina dear, there are many people who like them small, so get a grip. There was one chance to have her change in the finale of the second season, when she actually gets possessed by the Lord of Nightmares and Gourry… well, I won’t spoil it but it had me thinking the series finally got on a new track. But no, the goddamn scriptwriters decided to press the reset button and make everything appear like they never happened. And again now, her sister pops up all of a sudden and you think something will change or you will finally get to know more about her training years … and you get almost nothing. Same thing for all characters, they are there and don’t do anything character-wise. Heck, they hardly do anything story-wise when in 99% of the cases all problems are solved with a nice, cozy, warm, fluffy DRAGON SLAVE UP YOUR ASS! I like them, they are funny, but they never change and do feel rather boring by today’s gigolo-mastermind Lelouch-like standards. Characters get a 6.

Animation and sound are likable to the most part, although they never get to masterwork levels in any way. The use of colors and caricatures is way too “cartoony” and that may feel bad to most, while the backgrounds are usually typical medieval cities or ruins with occasionally some anachronisms thrown in just for extra joke. Major battles are very well made and are full of explosions and tension-built up, although the heroes have infinite hit points and Lina can always spam spells more powerful than the arch-demons, so that makes it kinda anti-climactic. The music score is likable and Hayashibara Megumi does as usually a great job as Lina’s voice actor. They are all nice to see and hear but don’t expect any heavy work or symbolism given to any of them. Animation and sound get a 7.

The historical value of the Slayers franchise is definitely high, as it was one of the most famous works of the 90’s and probably affected many following titles in its way of humor and character achetypes. At the same time, it lacks real development or deep sympathy for its cast, as down to it feels like a not-so-bold almost storyless comedy around an ever hungry, even frustrated, ever Dragon Slave spamming teenage girl with small breasts. It is good but it could be better. Value and Enjoyment get a 7.

Average: 6

SUGGESTION LIST
Mahoujin Guruguru
Dragon Half
Tower of Druaga
Ruin Explorers
roriconfan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2014-02-16, 21:59   Link #122
xxanimefan4_ever
Sorri++
 
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Quote:
Originally Posted by roriconfan View Post
At the same time, it lacks real development or deep sympathy for its cast, as down to it feels like a not-so-bold almost storyless comedy around an ever hungry, even frustrated, ever Dragon Slave spamming teenage girl with small breasts. It is good but it could be better. Value and Enjoyment get a 7.
i think your analysis is way-off... and how could you write the part about real development or real sympathy? did you not see slayers next? full metal alchemist whatever whaever never reaches anywhere near the level that slayers next reached imo. and obviously this show, especially slayers evolution-r, is most likely being watched by slayers fans and not "new-comers" to the slayers franchise. they should start at slayers. no duh.

i remember reading this somewhere else and was turned off. i don't think this is relevant this thread, don't copy paste stuff... post it on your blog if you want to post it on multiple places.
__________________
<3
xxanimefan4_ever is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 2014-02-16, 22:06   Link #123
GDB
Senior Member
 
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Age: 28
Quote:
Originally Posted by xxanimefan4_ever View Post
i remember reading this somewhere else and was turned off. i don't think this is relevant this thread, don't copy paste stuff... post it on your blog if you want to post it on multiple places.
You realize you're responding to a 3 and a half year old post by a member who's banned, right?
GDB is online now   Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
comedy, fantasy

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 13:56.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
We use Silk.