PDA

View Full Version : KanColle - Yokosuka Chinjufu-hen Anthology Manga Discussion


Miraluka
2013-11-13, 14:32
I made a thread to discuss about the manga adaptations this series has.

One of them seems to be done by Hisasi:
http://i.imgur.com/MnBux1Hl.jpg (http://imgur.com/MnBux1H)
http://i.imgur.com/ljpa8hol.jpg (http://imgur.com/ljpa8ho)
http://i.imgur.com/d0bjqqSl.jpg (http://imgur.com/d0bjqqS)
http://i.imgur.com/ck7PcwIl.jpg (http://imgur.com/ck7PcwI)

Requiem-x
2013-11-13, 22:41
That must be an anthology, which often has multiple doujin artists participating, in fact, I think the image in the bottom is from Hatsu Inu.

Anyway, right now my biggest priority is the Tatsuta and Tenryuu manga, which already seems like it could be fun, and the Akatsuki sisters are there too, so cuteness is guranteed. Good stuff.

Myssa Rei
2013-11-13, 22:57
Yes, that's a fan anthology. Aside from the 4koma, the official ones are the ones about Tatsuta and Tenryuu, and the Akatsuki-class destroyers.

bakapervert
2013-11-13, 23:04
Can someone explain to me what is this Kantai Collection actually is? Anime, OVA, trading card? I'm not really clear at what is this and how this suddenly become so popular.

Myssa Rei
2013-11-13, 23:06
Can someone explain to me what is this Kantai Collection actually is? Anime, OVA, trading card? I'm not really clear at what is this and how this suddenly become so popular.

Please go to this thread. (http://forums.animesuki.com/showthread.php?t=122413)

In short, moe IJN ship girls. See how it's been wedded to the hip to the Arpeggio anime's endcards.

As for popularity, many blame Kouta Hirano (aka Hellsing and Drifters' mangaka) ranting about his ship girls sinking on Twitter sometime in July.

Birdway
2013-11-23, 10:31
How is called the one from Hisasi?

I find this is his art style *-*.
http://i.imgur.com/BSSKwf6.jpg (http://imgur.com/BSSKwf6)

Bakaizer
2013-11-23, 11:41
How is called the one from Hisasi?

I find this is his art style *-*.
http://i.imgur.com/BSSKwf6.jpg (http://imgur.com/BSSKwf6)

is seems that this is official

Miraluka
2013-11-23, 11:53
Which artist is that?

Myssa Rei
2013-11-23, 20:09
Take note we have 3 comics out so far: the 4koma, the one focusing on Tenryuu and Tatsuta, and the one with Fubuki and the penguin teitoku.

Birdway
2013-12-05, 10:50
What this says about sales?
http://yaraon.blog109.fc2.com/blog-entry-20352.html

blitz1/2
2014-02-08, 01:22
Shimakaze chapter 2 is out! Yea, I definitely prefer this series over the other adaptations I read, I like the serious atmosphere.

Myssa Rei
2014-03-16, 00:18
Well, it's been way too quiet, especially since translated chapters of the more serious manga have been coming out.

Basically two more chapters for Shimakaze, Girl of the Whirlwind, as well as Itsuka.

The latter is a bit interesting, as it's the first time we've been shown the Wo-Class in print, and rather than cute or beautiful in an alien way, they're shown as legitimately creepy-looking.

Just a head's up.

Requiem-x
2014-03-16, 00:41
Well, it's been way too quiet, especially since translated chapters of the more serious manga have been coming out.

Basically two more chapters for Shimakaze, Girl of the Whirlwind, as well as Itsuka.

The latter is a bit interesting, as it's the first time we've been shown the Wo-Class in print, and rather than cute or beautiful in an alien way, they're shown as legitimately creepy-looking.

Just a head's up.

I certainly didn't expect them to be so creepy, that's for sure.

That submarine is serious nightmare fuel. Other than that, it's quite interesting to see the bizarre workings of the universe in action, like the little planes and the arrows that turn into planes.

Bizarre...

My only problem with Itsuka is that is clearly episodic, even more so than strike witches, which can be a bit frustrating. Not sure if the same will happen with Shimakaze's manga, but I'm certain there will be at least one chapter dedicated to the Yukiho of the group, which I don't exactly look forward to (Yukiho is the only girl scared of guys that I like). I hope we at least get a nice chapter with Atago and Takao.

Oh, and I really want to see the manga with the Akatsukis, because duh. Also, it seems their first task is quite big. Literally.

Irisu
2014-03-16, 06:28
I'm not liking the direction of Yamazaki Kazuma's kancolle manga is going.
I originally thought it'll deal more with warfare against deep sea fleet, but recently we've been dealing with Shimakaze's loner issues and not much about other things.

MrTerrorist
2014-03-16, 07:30
Any version with a Female Admiral?

LeaD36
2014-03-16, 07:34
I'm against Hisasi getting serialized. I keep losing all my favorite H-manga artists at this rate. Tosh I can forgive, because once you exceed godlike you can just reset your stats and conquer the world over the second gamemode (from H to Non-H).

I can't really imagine Hisasi drawing anything apart from Ecchi stuff though.

Master Assassin
2014-03-16, 07:37
So I take it by this thread that anthologies and other official works (Shimakaze, the 4koma, Calm Seas, even the novel etc) are fair game?

Got a few of these by print, and apparently I accidentally bought an extra anthology (serves me right for not checking before making the order).

There are a few more that I didn't buy yet, but mostly because I'm already out of moolahs for them. Didn't realize these anthologies have follow-up volumes. Well, it's a nice thing to know that they even exist, because most of the time I just assume anthologies are single-shots of a collection of selected strips.

Oddly enough, my current favorite out of the official series we have now is the Shimakaze manga. It's just that its rate of progression per chapter is a bit too painful to bear. There's more that makes me curious to know than just what has been shown in the chapters so far, but frankly I'm not that very good with... waiting...

(Also, yay for thread.)

Myssa Rei
2014-03-23, 19:50
That infodump in the Shimakaze manga. :heh: It's hilarious how it's pretty much Arpeggio of Blue Steel, except with literal shipgirls rather than mental models.

cloud04
2014-03-23, 20:09
ohh i remember the infinite blue i read before
cover kongou vs kongou lol

Newprimus
2014-03-23, 20:48
How is called the one from Hisasi?

I find this is his art style *-*.
http://i.imgur.com/BSSKwf6.jpg (http://imgur.com/BSSKwf6)

Actually none of them are done by Hisasi. In the OP, one of them resembles Kamiya Zuzu's. The one in yours looks done by Yahiro Pochi.

msg
2014-03-24, 00:34
I knew this series gonna be popular.:)

HERE (http://forums.animesuki.com/showthread.php?t=121164)

RRW
2014-04-25, 01:28
http://imgur.com/a/Gu0f0

Death Usagi
2014-04-25, 07:50
TwT no one is translating the Kancolle manga lately... :(

I want to see the 4th chapter of Shimakaze manga and the rest of the anthologies...

Only doujinshi get translated mostly... TwT

Requiem-x
2014-04-25, 08:01
TwT no one is translating the Kancolle manga lately... :(

I want to see the 4th chapter of Shimakaze manga and the rest of the anthologies...

Only doujinshi get translated mostly... TwT

The 4th chapter of the Shimakaze manga came out yesterday. Translated, I mean.

Death Usagi
2014-04-25, 08:03
The 4th chapter of the Shimakaze manga came out yesterday. Translated, I mean.

=w=; at 1am for me lol....

Requiem-x
2014-06-27, 09:51
Shimakaze isn't my favorite ship girl, but the author of what's supposed to be her manga seems to straight up hate her.

The latest chapter has newcomer Yuudachi wrecking her, and without torpedoes or the like, but kicking her in the gut.

I understand this is meant to be a serious approach to the series, and cheeky girls like Shimakaze need to get a lot of tough love, or just suffer to learn the lesson in those kind of stories, but this is painting her in a really negative way, as a weak, childish jerk who needs to be punished, and it probably doesn't help Yuudachi either, though this being her kai 2 form, it makes more sense for her to be so aggressive, but still, appearing so suddenly just go "you suck, step up, girl", I can't help to be reminded of a certain magical girl show that did the same, and it sucked.

Death Usagi
2014-07-03, 10:42
http://i.imgur.com/Jt7zq5O.png

This was just total win XD

Requiem-x
2014-07-03, 11:59
http://i.imgur.com/Jt7zq5O.png

This was just total win XD

The most adorable kind of bullying? :heh:

I'm glad they mentioned that's the sub's uniform, but now I'm thinking what sub could be small enough for Asashio to fit in it. Shioi?

Death Usagi
2014-07-03, 15:54
Female admiral such a troll :heh:

Death Usagi
2014-07-27, 15:28
Jesus lord, Yuudachi kai 2 vs Shimakaze and Asashio which I am guessing they aren't even Kai yet?

Of course both will lose when they are like total newbies.