PDA

View Full Version : AnimeSuki 2007 Choice awards! [Nominations] ~Read the rules.


Kyomi
2007-12-09, 18:23
Due to popular demand the thread has been re-posted >here< (http://forums.animesuki.com/showthread.php?p=1291318#post1291318) with more added categories and choices.

I'm sorry for those who already casted their vote and I encourage them to do so once again in the new thread.
So overall.

-More categories

-Repeated anime vote cast

-Time extended.

Also a list of eligible animes of 2007 is in progress and should be there shortly.

Mods: Please terminate this thread as you see fit.

jedinat
2007-12-09, 20:10
{A} (2)Hellsing (2006) (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=3296) - Ghost Hunt (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4564) - Red Garden (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4522)

{B} (2)Ichigo Mashimaro OVA (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4559) - Hayate no Gotoku! (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4917) - Doujin Work (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=5071)

{C} (2)Kanon (2006) (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4404) - Lovely Complex (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=5053) - Nana (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4143)

{D} (2)Maria-sama ga Miteru 3rd (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4138) - Nodame Cantabile (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4691)

{E} (2)Aria The OVA: Arietta (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=5115)

{F} (2)Alucard (Hellsing (2006) (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=3296))

{G} (2)Itoh Nobue (Ichigo Mashimaro OVA (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4559)) - Seras Victoria (Hellsing (2006) (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=3296)) - Fukuzawa Yumi (Maria-sama ga Miteru 3rd (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=4138))

{H} (2)Juuni Kokuki (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=26) - Trigun (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=53) - Haibane Renmei (http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=271)

Falkor
2007-12-09, 20:20
I think this is a great idea if done properly. As far as nomination concerns, it would be really helpful if you can run a list with all the anime eligible for the tournament. I know is a pain, but I’m having problems remembering all the anime that aired this year in order to make a good pick, instead of regretting my choice later on since nominating is also a “voting process.” Also, it wouldn’t hurt expanding the categories a bit more to include mecha, visual/novel adaptations, fantasy, magical girl(?), or any other you find important/popular since many shows fall into those as well. It has been irking me for a while that all the mecha shows would evidently go into action/sci fi and either that category will be filled with mecha shows or some mecha shows will go missing. On the other hand, a show like Clannad and many others can be regarded not only as comedy, but also as action/sci fi, romance, and drama. Making it fall into one obvious category would give more chance for other shows to get nominated into the actual tournament.

It just occurred to me if you can add something like the “worst show of the year” or “the show with the most wasted potential” just for fun. I think that’s it for now since I have no idea how you plan to run the actual tournament. Keep up the good work. :D

Before I forget, can I nominate for example the first half now and later on add the other half or I have to post my nominations all at once?

tripperazn
2007-12-09, 20:43
It would really help if someone could not only list all the anime, but also separate them into competition in which they are eligible. The vague way the sections are separated is only going to lead to fanboys wanting to nominate their favorite anime into virtually all categories. A line needs to be drawn before nominations even start to avoid all this hassle.

I have done many, many surveys with analysis in statistics classes. Even a single open ended question is a complete pain in the ass. If the entire nomination process is open it's going to be a lot more painful to tally later than if you just draw the line now.

If it really comes down to a borderline series with a lot of support for participation in other sections, you can leave it open to petitions.

Just a suggestion.

Kaioshin Sama
2007-12-09, 20:46
{A} (2)Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=6698) - Gundam 00 (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=8190) - Heroic Age (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=7627)

{B} (2)Moetan (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=8034) - Kodomo No Jikan (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=7688) - Hayate No Gotoku (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=7490)

{C} (2)iDOLM@STER Xenoglossia (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=7442)

{D} (2)Darker Than Black (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=7382) - Code Geass (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=6704)

{F} (2) Simon (Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=6698)) - Lelouch Vie Britannia (Code Geass (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=6704)) - Kamina (Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=6698))

{G} (2) Kagami Kuro (Kodomo No Jikan (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=7688)) - C.C (Code Geass (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=6704)) - Elise Von Dietrich (Sky Girls (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=7816))

{H} (2)Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=6698) - Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=1381) -Legend Of The Galactic Heroes (http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/search?cx=016604166282602569737%3Aznd1ysjewre&cof=FORID%3A11&q=legend+of+the+galactic+heroes)

Kyomi
2007-12-09, 20:54
Hmm.. I'll agree there could have been a list of the shows, as far as I know it might not be too late to make one. But as far as the categories goes, I was concerned about the number of responses from the members and intentionally tried to keep it low. Let's just say if this goes well there might be more next time. This is more of a test-thread to see if anyone is willing to participate in such an award thread. Though now launched it's a tad bit late to change it.
[Edit: Stares at the 2007 list...: Zetsubo:]

Lanner Falcon
2007-12-09, 21:11
{A} (2)Code Geass - Baccano - Mobile Suit Gundam 00

{B} (2)Doujin Work - Lucky Star - Minami-ke

{C} (2)Myself; Yourself - Blue Drop - ef ~ A Tale of Memories

{D} (2)Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai - Darker Than Black - Death Note

{E} (None)

{F} (2) Hei (Darker Than Black) - Maebara Keiichi (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai) - Hiro ( ef ~ A Tale of Memories)

{G} (2) Furude Rika - (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai) - Konata (Lucky StarI) - Miyako (ef ~ A Tale of Memories)

{H} (2) Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai - ef ~ A Tale of Memories - Myself; Yourself

patnam
2007-12-09, 21:31
{A} (2)Code Geass - Claymore - Mobile Suit Gundam 00

{B} (2)Lucky Star - Kodomo no Jikan - Goshusama Ninomiya-Kun

{C} (2)Myself; Yourself - Clannad - ef ~ A Tale of Memories

{D} (2)Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai - KimiKiss ~pure rouge~ - School Days

{E} (2)Koharu Biyori (OVA) - Kodomo no Jkan (OVA)

{F} (2) Lelouch Lamperouge (Code Geass) - Makoto Ito (School Days) - Kazuma Yagami (Kaze no Stigma)

{G} (2) Teresa (Claymore) - Katsura Kotonoha (School Days) - C.C. (Code Geass)

{H} (2) School Rumble - ef ~ A Tale of Memories - Code Geass

Vanehei
2007-12-09, 21:50
-{A} (2) Darker than Black - Ghost hunt- Ghost hound

-{B} (2) Nodame Cantabile - Lucky star -

-{C}(2)Romeo X Juliet -

-{D} (2) Rental Magical - Myself yourself -

-{E}(2) 5 cm per second

-{F} (2) Hei (darker than Black)

-{G}(2) Nodame (nodame Cantabile)

And finally the exception:

-{H} (2) Monster- Darker than Black - Nodame Cantabile

Shana
2007-12-09, 22:24
- {A} (2) Blue Drop - Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - Code Geass
- {B} (2) Lucky Star - Minami-ke - Shugo Chara!
- {C} (2) Sola - Myself; Youserlf - ef ~ a tale of memories
- {D} (2) CLANNAD - Bamboo Blade - School Days
- {E} (2) Candy Boy
- {F} (2) Shiraishi Minoru (Lucky Star)
- {G} (2) Sakurai Yukine (Candy Boy)

And the exception:

- {H} (2) Kamichu! - Candy Boy - CLANNAD

SeijiSensei
2007-12-09, 22:44
I'm having a bit of trouble with the categories.

What category does Seirei no Moribito fall into? (I'm a bit shocked it has yet to be nominated so far!) Could be action, could be drama. I'd call it drama, but then some people have put CLANNAD there as well, which seems like a very different type of show to me. What about Dennou Coil (also shockingly unmentioned so far)? Is it sci-fi or drama? I'm guessing the former in this case, yet then it'll be competing against Claymore, which again seems like a hard comparison to draw.

I guess my problem is that (D) seems like a catch-all category for anything not in the mainstream genres so it's going to be hard to make comparisons.

I'm not trying to nit-pick here, but I'd agree with those folks who think having a categorized list would clarify this process considerably.

There's a list of shows linked in the SaiGar thread covering the period 12/1/06-11/30/07. That might be a good starting point. I recently did some compilations from the AniDB database. A search using "year:2007" turned up about 350 entries. Perhaps a few AniDB searches by year and genre would provide well-categorized lists? I'll be happy to help out if you'd like.

White Manju Bun
2007-12-09, 22:57
{A} Action/Sci-Fi : (2) Code Geass - Ghost Hunt - Mononoke

-{B} Comedy : (2) Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei - Gintama

-{C} Romance : (2) Kanon 06 - Romeo x Juliet

-{D} Drama, Slice of Life and the likes. (2) Bokurano - Shion no Ou - Death Note

-{E} Favorite Short (Movies and OVA)

-{F} Favorite Male character: (2) Naru (Ghost Hunt) - Medicine Seller (Mononoke) - Lelouch (Code Geass)

-{G} Favorite Female character: (2) Teresa (Claymore) - Kallen (Code Geass) -

And finally the exception:

-{H} All time favorite : (2) Full Metal Alchemist - Ouran Highschool Host Club - Ghost Hunt

I think I did this right :heh:

Sorrow-K
2007-12-09, 23:03
I'm having a bit of trouble with the categories.

What category does Seirei no Moribito fall into? (I'm a bit shocked it has yet to be nominated so far!) Could be action, could be drama. I'd call it drama, but then some people have put CLANNAD there as well, which seems like a very different type of show to me. What about Dennou Coil (also shockingly unmentioned so far)? Is it sci-fi or drama? I'm guessing the former in this case, yet then it'll be competing against Claymore, which again seems like a hard comparison to draw.

I guess my problem is that (D) seems like a catch-all category for anything not in the mainstream genres so it's going to be hard to make comparisons.

I'm not trying to nit-pick here, but I'd agree with those folks who think having a categorized list would clarify this process considerably.

There's a list of shows linked in the SaiGar thread covering the period 12/1/06-11/30/07. That might be a good starting point. I recently did some compilations from the AniDB database. A search using "year:2007" turned up about 350 entries. Perhaps a few AniDB searches by year and genre would provide well-categorized lists? I'll be happy to help out if you'd like.
Yeah, this is my problem with all of this. Almost anything that can be considered worthy of an award will have some sort of drama in it. But, almost anything that can be considered worthy of an award will easily fall into multiple categories. Take Nodame Cantabile, for example, which, IMO, is the best anime of the year by a long way. It's already been nominated for both Comedy and Drama, and it could also be nominated for Romance if one wished. It's susceptible to having its votes split among multiple categories, which I think would make it harder for it to make it through to the next round.

I'll save my nominations for later. Need to think about it.

minhtam1638
2007-12-09, 23:10
I smell an AMV coming our way.

My nominations:

Official Co-Hosts: Kamina & Yoko (Gurren Lagaan)

-{A} Action/Sci-Fi - (2) Gurren Lagaan, (1) Shakugan no Shana II

-{B} Comedy - (2) Hayate no Gotoku, (1) Lucky Star

-{C} Romance - (2) Kanon 2006, (1) Clannad

-{D} Drama, Slice of Life and the likes. - (2) Lucky Star, (1) Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai

-{E} Favorite Short (Movies and OVA) - no nominations

-{F} Favorite Male character - (2) Kamina - Gurren Lagaan, (1) Simon - Gurren Lagaan, (1) Okazaki Tomoya - Clannad

-{G} Favorite Female character - (2) Shana - Shakugan no Shana, (1) Kawasumi Mai - Kanon 2006, (1) Ichinose Kotomi - Clannad

-{H} All time favorite - (2) Fate/Stay Night, (1) Kanon 2006, (1) Chrono Crusade

siya
2007-12-09, 23:13
-{A} Action/Sci-Fi- Naruto Shippuden- Mobile Suit Gundam 00- Ghost hunt

-{B} Comedy- (2) Lucky Star- Shugo Chara!- Nodame Cantabile

-[C} Romance- (2) Myself; Youserlf - Kanon 06

-{D} Drama, Slice of Life and the likes.- (2) Death Note- Bokurano- School Days

-{E} Favorite Short (Movies and OVA)- (2)Zombie-Loan

-{F} Favorite Male character- (2) L (Death Note)- Tobi (Naruto) Hanataro (Bleach)

-{G} Favorite Female character- (2) Misa (Death Note)

-{H} All time favorite - (2) Card Captor Sakura -Pokemon- Full Metal Alchemist

Ascaloth
2007-12-09, 23:15
{A} Action/Sci-Fi : (2) Death Note

-{B} Comedy : (2) Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei - Lucky Star

-{C} Romance : (2) CLANNAD (TV)

-{D} Drama, Slice of Life and the likes. (2) CLANNAD (TV) - Kanon (2006) - ef ~ a tale of memories

-{E} Favorite Short (Movies and OVA). (2) Byousoku 5cm

-{F} Favorite Male character: (2) Aizawa Yuuichi (Kanon 2006) - Okazaki Tomoya (CLANNAD TV) - Yagami Light (Death Note)

-{G} Favorite Female character: (2) Furukawa Nagisa (CLANNAD TV) - Shihou Matsuri (Sola)

-{H} All time favorite : (2) Full Metal Panic? The Second Raid - Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu! - CLANNAD (TV)

Kaioshin Sama
2007-12-09, 23:33
{A} Action/Sci-Fi : (2) Death Note

-{B} Comedy : (2) Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei - Lucky Star

-{C} Romance : (2) CLANNAD (TV)

-{D} Drama, Slice of Life and the likes. (2) CLANNAD (TV) - Kanon (2006) - ef ~ a tale of memories

-{E} Favorite Short (Movies and OVA). (2) Byousoku 5cm

-{F} Favorite Male character: (2) Aizawa Yuuichi (Kanon 2006) - Okazaki Tomoya (CLANNAD TV) - Yagami Light (Death Note)

-{G} Favorite Female character: (2) Furukawa Nagisa (CLANNAD TV) - Shihou Matsuri (Sola)

-{H} All time favorite : (2) Full Metal Panic? The Second Raid - Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu! - CLANNAD (TV)

You do realize you have Clannad on there twice right?

WanderingKnight
2007-12-09, 23:43
I don't really like how the categories were divided... but what the hell.

-{A} Action/Sci-Fi: (2) Baccano! - Code Geass: Lelouch of the Rebellion - Darker Than Black
-{B} Comedy: (2) Ichigo Mashimaro OVA - Seto no Hanayome
-{C} Romance: (2) Kanon 2006 (haven't been watching many romance series lately :/)
-{D} Drama, Slice of Life and the likes: (2) Sketchbook ~full color'S~ - Bokurano - Ghost Hound
-{E} Favorite Short (Movies and OVA): (2) Byousoku 5cm - Ghost In The Shell SAC: Solid State Society - ARIA The OVA ~ Arietta
-{F} Favorite Male Character - (2) Lelouch Lamperouge (Code Geass) - Hei (Darker Than Black) - Anime Tenchou (Lucky Star)
-{G} Favorite Female Character - (2) C.C. (Code Geass) - Kusanagi Motoko (GITS SAC Solid State Society) - Sora (Sketchbook)

-{H} All Time Favorite: (2) Neon Genesis Evangelion - Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex 2nd GIG - Chikyuu Shoujo Arjuna

gaguri
2007-12-09, 23:45
Get rid of A to D for obvious reasons as mentioned above. It's much better to give awards for their technical merits in different departments. Just to quickly brainstorm several areas,
best visuals (not just how pretty it looks, but how visuals help telling the story, etc.)
best soundtracks (not just how good it sounds, but how the music help set the mood, etc.)
best voice acting
best script
best character design
best directing
best action (as in, which anime had the best animated action sequences, not the best anime with any action scenes)
best comedy (likewise, which anime had the best comedic moments, make you laugh)
, and so on.

Or maybe you'd like to give awards to the below areas,
best horror/suspense/thriller (anime that had the creepiest/most tense moments)
best tearjerker
best design of the world (as in, originality behind it, details behind the art and little things that add more to the world, etc...basically, which anime had the most intriguing and fascinating world)

Just some of the ideas, by no means a perfect list, but if you're going to do this properly, even as a mere 'test', you should come up with a better organised and more effective categories before taking further nominations. Also, I don't think we need to nominate three for each category, one should be more than enough. Just a thought.

And please, it'd be nice to have a link to a list, or even better, copy and paste the list into a spoiler form, so people can choose from the list. It's bothersome, but it may prevent more people from giving excuses 'o I didn't know this anime started before 2007'.

Kaioshin Sama
2007-12-09, 23:48
Get rid of A to D for obvious reasons as mentioned above. It's much better to give awards for their technical merits in different departments. Just to quickly brainstorm several areas,
best visuals (not just how pretty it looks, but how visuals help telling the story, etc.)
best soundtracks (not just how good it sounds, but how the music help set the mood, etc.)
best voice acting
best script
best directing
best action (as in, which anime had the best animated action sequences, not the best anime with any action scenes)
best comedy (likewise, which anime had the best comedic moments, make you laugh)
, and so on.

If you're going to do this properly, even as a mere 'test', you should come up with a better organised and more effective categories before taking further nominations. Also, I don't think we need to nominate three for each category, one should be more than enough.

Or maybe expand the current list to include such categories.

Honey_and_Cleaver
2007-12-09, 23:50
-{A} (2) Gundam 00

-{B} (2) Sayonara Zetsubou Sense - Doujin Work - Moyashimon

-{C} (2) Kimikiss pure rouge

-{D} (2) Minami ke

-{E} (2) Mobile Suit Gundam:Stargazer

-{F}(2) Kazuma Yagami (Kaze no Stigma) - Zed(Kiba) - Brandon Heat(Gungrave)

-{G} Suigintou(Rozen Maiden) - Chikane(Kannazuki no Miko)

And finally the exception:

-{H} Kaze no Stigma - Gungrave - Scryed

SeedFreedom
2007-12-10, 00:04
-{A} Action/Sci-Fi: gundam 00

-{B} Comedy: minami-ke

-{C} Romance CLannad ; ef a tale of memories

-{D} Drama, Slice of Life and the likes. myself; yourself; Shakugan no shana II


-{F} Favorite Male character: Shuu(myself yourself) ; Sana (myself yourself) ; Sonohara (Clannad)

-{G} Favorite Female character Tomoyo (Clannad) ; Toa (Dragonaut); Shana (shakugan no shana II)

And finally the exception:

-{H} All time favorite: Scrapped Princess; Utawarerumono ; Fate/Stay Night

Also, i think the catagories could be broken up a little more. Also i dont see why one anime cant be nominated for multiple catagories. It works that way for the Emmies.

As well take all my first picks as the one worth 2 points

NoSanninWa
2007-12-10, 01:42
Due to popular demand the thread has been re-posted >here< (http://forums.animesuki.com/showthread.php?p=1291318#post1291318) with more added categories and choices.

I'm sorry for those who already casted their vote and I encourage them to do so once again in the new thread.
So overall.

-More categories

-Repeated anime vote cast

-Time extended.

Also a list of eligible animes of 2007 is in progress and should be there shortly.This thread is closed, please go to the new one and revote.