As long as you don't force them to watch it with you I do not see why it would bother them! But this is coming from an anime fan so it makes sense why I don't understand them lol... Things are good in the big apple and I agree with your girlfriend, you should move, it's more exciting here, NY is expensive so settle for Connecticut maybe? Its close but much cheaper and you will have a happy girlfriend on your hands
PS. I only said I feel kind of old so you can shower me with compliments of how young I look, damn you! :P LOL