Well... I don't agree entirely, but I have seen worse, so I guess Asuki isn't all that bad? But yes, as a practical matter, a dictatorship (ranging in scope from benign to malevolent) is the only practical way forums can be run.
That said, if you're wanting to use analogies in future, I still think saying you guys are Judges is a bit more accurate than dictators!
And yes, I've seen the remake.
(Many times.) For a film shot on a shoestring budget, I totally agree, it's one of the best all time action films, ever. I particularly liked Karl Urban's calm quiet portrayal of Dredd: "Ma-ma's not the law. I am the Law."
This is a man who doesn't need to shout or announce anything to the world, a man who knows himself and is secure in that knowledge and self confidence. (Reminds me of something I'd seen before: "Arrogance is when you can back it up, conceit is when you can't.") As one person on Spacebattles put it, for Anderson, the movie was a hellish baptism of fire into the life of a street judge that rocked her to her very core and changed the way she saw herself and the world around her.
For Dredd, it was a drug bust.
