Quote:
I agree that Saber was a bit subpar in Fate/Zero
|
Saber is as much a character that is the anti of what Urobuchi believes that could possibly exist. He never would have understood how to handle that woman. The motorcycle was amusing, though. Aside from that, the misogyny was glaring and he tarnished Saber so very much. There's a reason people sided with Riber and trashed Saber in droves after Episode 11.
Quote:
Kariya was actually really good. I felt sorry for him and knew that his way was wrong but it shows how good intentions can pave the road to hell.
|
It was clear from the get-go that he was delusional and throwing himself away for nothing. Good intentions or not, committing evil for the sake of good intentions is the actions of a complete fool who deserves their own destruction. Watching Kariya be trolled all series is not something I can sympathise with since it was so bleeding obvious he made the wrong choices and ended up achieving nothing.
quote]I thought every character had their role, though certainly there were roadbumps.[/quote]
Kiritsugu had a role but aside from the 2 flashback episodes, I really didn't give a damn about him at all. Again, someone who was able to come to the conclusion killing some people would save others was destined for oblivion. Killing can never lead to happiness. The rationalisation that it can requires a mentality as juvenile as Light. Anyone associated with Kiritsugu seemed to act in the hope that one day he'd see how wrong he was. For the sake of the whole story and what would happen in FSN, he eventually did. But for someone who threw away their humanity and killed their own father with such absence of feeling - I can't feel sympathy for that. Kiritsugu was a victim of a cruel world. But if you let it get to you so easily and commit cruelty in return, you are merely repeating the cycle and becoming everything that you despised and wished to destroy. Kiritsugu was someone who wished to be a hero but due to his own stupid decisions, he became the anti-hero. His origins were interesting but the product itselff was dull. Absolutely dull and juvenile.
Kotomine eventually became a worthy antagonist but taking so damn long to become remotely interesting to do so and having Gilgamesh being the one pulling the strings. The product at the end of the show is well set up for the awesome bastard he is in FSN. But that doesn't make up for the fact he was an utter bore for so damn long and that he was utterly easy for Gilgamesh to manipulate. I can't care about someone who initially whined the same way as Shinji Ikari. Really, I feel that Urobuchi was living himself during Kotomine at this point in his life and had a ball with him. However, Kotomine had a point and it was fulfilled. That can't be disputed.
Gilgamesh - I guess there's not much I can say that wasn't done right with Gilgamesh. But hey, considering how much of a foundation Nasu had set up already, it's not like Urobuchi did anything with Gilgamesh that Nasu wouldn't have. Still, the bastard was done as he should be. Can't say anything bad about this one.
Rider - I'm going to be blunt. I truly felt Rider was a device to be the attention-grabber when the more important characters in the title were at their dullest and the title couldn't afford them to take up that much screen time, so Rider flaunting in S1 and early S2 was a gap-filler because there certainly hasn't been that many legitimately GAR characters in recent times. But once the main characters FINALLY decide to come out and play, it becomes clear Rider is close to all talk and one of the weaker Servants, which really undermines his GARness. It doesn't even come close to Archer's last stand in FSN. Rider had the potential to be awesome yet in the end turned out to his bark was far more than his bite. Real shame.
Lancer - Now here was one of the characters I was looking forward to until I read far enough in the light novels. For one of the legitimately cool characters who seemed to have big potential, boy was he tossed aside. Okay, I figured a fate that sullied his honor was inevitable. But yikes...way to utterly rubbish the character. Lancer was wasted. He was merely excess baggage to Urobuchi and a way to make the pursuit of honor be a folly one.