Greetings. Just a little note after our discussion: I suggest you to check the post of someone you are quoting right after you made multiple quotes, as I noticed you often make an early quote, missing potential edit that occured between the initial post and the time of your post (which actually happened in the saki thread).

Sol, was that you as Nom de Plume over on Random Curiousity? If so, thanks for backing me up.

David

It's Ok. Thanks for clearing things up in PM.

Still, I felt compelled to defend my reasoning on Sayaka and Homura's narration a bit. Your other criticisms I accept without complaint, since they're more an issue of reader reception and taste than anything else, and I do see where you're coming from on them.

Ouch, Sol, that was an awfully critical response. You basically seemed to dislike everything about Chapter 9...

Just read your reply to Chapter 8 of Madoka Magica: Pure Pink Pretty Lovers.

Was curious if you were seriously bothered or not with how Madoka is ending up heterosexual in the Opportunity Choice endings.

With the latest one, at least, I can easily make the drug dealer who dates Madoka into a girl. I made him a guy since, well, when I think of shady drug dealers that seduce girls into doing heavy drugs, I just think "Male" for some reason.

Anyway, thanks for the response! Just so you know, I think that the best Sayaka and Homura romance routes will be in the canon path (the high drama situations produced by the canon anime narrative lends itself to better romance, imo), so that's one reward for people who stick to the anime narrative.

You know, I didn't even know before that Karen and Sayaka had the same seiyu. Now that I do, I think I have a greater appreciation for Nise. Thank you for that.

Yeah, I just recently watched the latest Nise episode, and that first half confrontation between Karen and the antagonist certainly did give me heavy Sayaka vibes.

Thanks a lot for giving me feedback after each chapter of my fanfic! It really helps to keep me motivated to write more. I'm glad you like how I try to put a bit of twist on each divergence from the anime.

But yeah, I'd encourage you to keep track of all your choices in a WordPad or NotePad file somewhere, since the sheer number of them will add up over time, and there will come a point when you'll need to calculate what your affection is with at least one other girl.

lol. What, are you making a poll? If you're a Suzaku fan, I don't know if it'd be such a great idea to call out all of the haters purposely...
It's true but I don' know make a poll ^^" May you help me?

Happy Halloween! Hope it was a fun-filled one for you.