I can assure you that Reckoner is on the level. He doesn't follow shows just to gripe about them...well at least not for more than a couple episodes and I find his criticisms to usually if not always be on point and fair. When we do disagree I recognize where he's coming from at the very least, which is more than I can say for some posters who have already sounded off about Gundam AGE. Reckoner is definitely enjoying the show so far and he does definitely enjoy anime as I've witnessed in his posts and through watching shows with him.
Needless to say Reckoner should IMO be the least of your worries on this forum. Together we'll focus our energy on the truly unreasonable critics and hopefully see them outed, but Reckoner is definitely not one of them.