black0raz0r: Nice, 8.7/10
Chaos : Changmin is a bit bright, but good idea and execution. 8.8/10

Endrance : Nice animation, 8/10.

Ganbaru : Seems like a bad quality or oversharpened. Fix that and less text and it would be great. 7/10.

.. Have you ever though about inserting the text like I do ? Not in the signature itself because it always will be out of place, but when the signature is hovered over ? Hover over mine to see what I mean.

Haladflire65 : 9.6/10 Nice sig for Masha's b'day :D
The Chaos : 9.2/10 Swweett!
Hooves : 9.2/10 Nice as always.
Ganbaru : 9/10 Too bright but nice
Dist : 9.4/10 Lovely. Is it by Patchy-sama? Just asking :)

Butterfly: 7/10 (It would be nice if those butterfly glittering, but to me, i just looks like a blur from afar :) )

Dist: 7/10 (I can`t say anything except cute, but it is just Madoka so 7 for it :) )

Dist 8,9/10 good work from Patchy
Butter Fly 8,5/10 ypu should remouve those ''butterfly''
Shion Sanada 8,3/!0 not much to say

@ Dist I place text outside my signature only if it's the translation of the main text.

@Dist Patchy's style sure is recognizable, and verrry good. That is one by him, right? I'll feel like a bit of a fool if otherwise... 8.9/10

@Shion Shanda I just feel like saying that I once had a signature depicting a Chinese warrior (implied to be Sun Zi) and right below the signature, I had that exact same quote :heh: Ah, good times. 8/10

Butter Fly: Seconding ganbaru, 8.5/10
Dist: Pretty good. 8.8/10
ganbaru: Mmmm, the render looks a bit oversharpened. 8.6/10
Mr. Wang: Not bad, but I think it could stand to lose a render or two. 8.7/10

Is it always out of 10 when it comes to rating?

okay so let'd do it just like the others.

Haladfire65 - oh Masaharu 8.5//10
Mr.Wang - IPOD silhouette right? 8.25//10
ganbaru - where is that from? looks scary 8.25//10
ShionSanada - to be honest nothing special 5//10
ButterFly - Blurry 7//10
Dist - MADOKA!!!<3 10//10. just asking is it from the same artists whom I got my sig in the avatar request thread, since I don't found that sig there?

Forgive my insufficient knowledge in english

Mr Wang 8,5/10 did I rated this one before ?
Madoka Kaname 8,8/10 good work from Patchy

Madoka : Beautiful work by Patchy. I was tempted to swap my current signature for the one you took and one another, but I guess now I'll have to stay with mine. Madoka ftw ^^. 10/10

Dist: 9.8/10 very nicely done sig.
Butter Fly: 8/10 seconding ganbaru as well, the quality is a bit low as well and a border would be nice even a simple one.
ganbaru: 8.8/10 overall nice but render feels to saturated for me.
Mr. Wang: 9.5/10 i don't like apple but nice sig style is nice :P.
Madoka Kaname: 9.5/10 looks nice.

^Not bad, but you may want to change the text in your profile. It still says character : Shimizu Megumi from Shiki :heh: 7/10.

And Madoka : Yes, it's by Patchy. I only use signatures made by Patchy. This was kinda like a private request which is why it's not in his thread. Or well, it actually should be in some previous pages but anyway.

deloran: Not sure about the stroke around the render :D 8.5/10

delorean2200 8,4/10 interesting

ganbaru : 9/10 Nice as always :)
Delorean : 8.9/10 Sweet blue!

wonderfull~!
 

errr.... butterfly!!!
i think i saw that anime girl before but where??? :confused:
i like it how it can seems to like "glows" ;)
well anyways, that's good sign~
i'll say 9.5/10

Rakhool: Very cute 9.1/10 and I think for butterfly's sig she's the girl from the illusionary world in clannad.

Butter Fly 9/10 simply great
Rahkool 8,7/10 you should read the rules about signatures...
Konagata 8,8/10 might be a littel too bright at the right side

Butter Fly: Great work by Patchy, but not sure about the sig's overall flow. 8.8/10
Rahkool: Seconding ganbaru, 8.7/10
Konakaga: Pretty good, 8.8/10
ganbaru: Nice one, 8.7/10

Halad-8.6/10 I love blue...but you should lay off a bit :heh: