Comics Party Revolution, Shuffle! and Lamune...

Apparently I'm the only person in the world who actually didn't like AIR...

Nah. There's a lot of people that disliked AIR in the "Worst anime of 2005" thread. I find that thread very funny reading. :D

Shuffle! was definitively the best for 2005 though I haven't saw AIR

Shuffle!

But it wasn't amazing either. 2005 was kinda bad for this type of anime in my opinion.

You are not the only one. Thought it was boring never bother finishing it.

Lamune and AIR, and then Shuffle! I might have said Canvas2, until the ending.

AIR wasn't quite as well dramatized as it could have been, but it was still excellent, IMO. The drama and production values were far superior to Lamune, but Lamune had something special: a touch of YKK, as well as Gotou Yuuko (Nanami).

ToHeart had some enjoyable episodes, and a nice ending.

Shuffle! was blah until around halfway through, then it became interesting. Unlike some, I had no problem with the final arc. And it had Gotou Yuuko, too (Kaede).

hmmm, i'm a bit shocked that da'capo and to heart 2 didn't get many votes so far. i can understand why air and shuffle! are higher but i would have thought that these two may have had a few more.
oh well

Sorry it didn't include the bondage theme you would have liked.

AIR all the way. Shuffle 2nd I didn't care much for the rest I don't have that much space on my puter.

* AIR. Ok, it was pretty sad, but it's was still well done.
* Nanoha A's. I liked the ending :D
* To Heart 2. To Heart Fanatic :D
*Da Capo SS. I don't know what people have against Nemu. Plus, this show was as good as the first season.

I'd have voted Canan, too, but the ending had a small thing that annoyed me. But the last episodes were very good, and I was tempted.

I'd have voted Canvas 2, it was excellent until the last 10 seconds after the credits :p