Rate That Signature!
 

The previous version of this thread can be found here.

Thread Rules:

1. If you post here, you have to rate a signature. Please remember…this thread isn’t for personal chats. You must rate someone’s signature every time you post.
   
   Example Rating System: (just an example)
   
   http://img390.imageshack.us/img390/4...thia3xu2lz.jpg
   Thany: 8.7/10 – Awesome cute. I like your choice of font for your name. The blue eyes and chibi fang in her smile really make that image.
   
   http://img467.imageshack.us/img467/271/inu1tj4rw8vh.gif
   Inuzuka - 9.5/10 – Love the Beatnik minimalism. Excellent choice of font. Overall look isn’t quintessentially modern Anime, but the feel sure is.
   
   
2. When creating signature images, please read and abide by the Signature Rules. Signature images exceeding the size limits will be removed and sent to the signature rehabilitation center.
   
   
3. Please be polite and constructive when rating other people’s signatures. Curt assessment such as "That’s crap." or "Sucks." are useless and unwelcome. Try to give the person you're rating some useful feedback.
   
   
4. Have fun and be creative. :)

@ Catgirls Cute. But not a catgirl!! WTF append!? :p

I love it the transparency is impecable and its pretty small just like the Mods like them right. ^^

JOJOS'STAR: Is she pregnant? New fetish? .... j/k It looks nice, and it's definitely you. 8.10

Lol you crazy perv she is not pregnant?! what makes you think that? Which one? :p

@ Shay Your old sig is great. And your avatar makes me wonder why I havent put up one like that. :confused: hehee..

=O we gotta start over again >.< and i just got my second little box >.<

JOJOS'STAR rather revealing >.> tho i cant help but like it in my deep down subconious perverted mind >.>; ...

Shay tis cute and animated cant really find any faults so nice overall

Catgirls awww is quite cute in its own chibi sorta way...

i just made a few while suki was down to pass the time so C&C on which u thin is the nicest !

http://xs59.xs.to/pics/05500/cass.png
http://xs59.xs.to/pics/05500/casshern1.png

Wewt. It's good to be back.

Anyways, I just want to point out Catgirls that the link in your post points to the Rate that Avatar thread. Might want to change that ;)

On to ratings!

JoJo: It seems that you can post images again, and an ecchi one this is! True style of the Hentai Army. The actual composition of the signature is simple, but it most definitely gets points for being eye catching. 9.1/10

Shay: Wow, I remember that sig. It was animated though, wasn't it? Anyways, it's still nice :) 9.1/10

Drake: (rating the actual signature)No longer my nemesis :( Oh well... I tried. Anyways, I really like this one. I like the double border, but it's sort of ruined at the top right (the picture is coming through). The "Casshern" is also a little difficult to read. Nice job though :) 9.3/10

@JOJOS'STAR - The innershadow on the text doesn't look good at all. Otherwise it's quite a nice crop.

@Drake - Your current is good as per usual, but the other two (though not that different) are too much like generic sigs from sig forums. They're nice, but your sigs normally stand out, those two don't do it for me :P

• Drake - Pretty cool, but I can't really tell what it's supposed to be A-
• JOJOS'STAR - It'd be better if the girl on the right is actually placed farther to the back B
• Shay - A bit plain, but at least its symmetrical C+
• Catgirls - You should get Inuzuka(I think that's the right person) to get special effects for that xmas sig C

__________________
...

tabris - nice sig of ama. cool color for the bg. oh! and it has an chibi-asa :) 10/10

Drake-I really like that signature (the first one) 9/10, in the second one the guy looks a bit dead. On another note, was Casshern that japanese movie where the main character dies, and then this eletric metal thing comes from the sky and he comes back to life?
Yuiichi- 8/10 Overall pretty good, I just don't like the border for some reason
Tabrid- 8/10 For some reason the girl on her shoulder looks out of place, like it was photoshopped on.
Cyz-8.5 Pretty well done. Don't know what else to say:heh:

JOJOS'STAR

Wow, as i would expect from you, though i find a few things i didn't like, namely the empty space on the top, the colour of the character, the blurish border, and the poor dropshadow of the cut-out wordings. 6.5/10

Drake

Wow, a Casshern, this makes me want to drag out my old Casshern sig, which i won't since it sucks very bad. Anyway onto you, my main complain is the 'Casshern' wording is a bit blur, and i didn't really like the uneven pixelated curve lines on the top-right and bottom-left. 7/10

Yuiichi

I rated yours before, i just want to say i still like it.

Tabris

Cool as always, though the smaller chibi-character didn't seem to match in well with the larger character. 8/10

yuiichi: blood+ is a great show :D 10/10

drake: matches your ava I like it: 9/10

hmm no need for rating mine since its a club thing and won't be changing anytime soon. even when it does it will be related.

Kyuuen - nice sig of shizuru and natsuki 9/10

Cyz, any sig with Rukia gets at least a seven from me :love: Yours looks really kewl, I like the background. I've seen cuter pics of Rukia, 'tho ;) : 9/10

Cyc - 8/10, bleach sig come out nicely, althought i'd like to se some blending.

EfrainMan - 7/10 lol fairly clever. borders are nicer though ;)

efrainman - the nine tailed demon fox! 8/10
sasuraihell - a nice kaname pic. though i really wanna see the face. BG looks good 7/10

It was :)

@Cyz - Nice.
@SasuraiHell - Simple, but I like that a lot.

Tabris: I like it. It's simple yet effectively cute. XD

8/10

@Tabris: Sweet! 7/10 :)

SirHellsing420 - The stock image is really nice, although there's something odd about the proportion/balance to it.

applechewer_ - Could use some more detail, and the embossed/blurred border doesn't appear to fit the sig all too well. Interesting quote.

Tabris - I'm not the bigest Asa fan, but this signatures nice. The light effect on the text works well with the background.

I guess this is the signature I had back in January.

Avaj LMAO 10/10, great use of it ^_^


mine a bit too big?, oh well take a quick look

applechewer: johan = 9/10

sasurihell: I think that size is against the rules >.> its kind of pixely 6/10

SasuraiHell - A very nice Sakura pic ->9.5/10
GATX207 Blitz - Chibi Mint and who's the other one...anyway, cool! -> 9/10

Sorry, THIS was the one I made a mistake in

JOJO & SHAY: The Hentai Army returns 9.9/10
Ajav: 8/10, cause it reminded of the first episode of Bleach I watched.
Reflection: Love the Beck sig, even better is the smiley of FireFox 9/10
________
Michigan Marijuana Dispensary

Itachikun 6/10 - It made me smile. x3

mooooooo i thought no one was postiing in rate the sig thread... today i realised it was locked.... oh well

etooo who to rateee

jojo lol - women again - ur making me want to put em in my sig lol.

i dont really want to comment but ill rate it 8+/10 :P

I wouldnt normally reply since im stillll using my old sig - still enjoying my holls not wanting to make new one yet :D - anyway just wanted to subscribe myself to this thread.

Wavie - Lol I remeber this sig since I 1st joined AS, The text doesnt fit it well though. 7/10

SasuraiHell - The only sig ever where Sakura actually looks hott. 9/10

Wavie: Not bad, it's a little too dark though. 6/10

mxg: Heh, it's kinda bland for my tastes. I do like its ripple effect, though. 6/10

mxg - it's cool but it still need something 7/10
SirHellsing420 - nice sig. i like the bg and the shading done 9/10

2ndHanOfTime: Looks like a nice motive, awful quality though.
Wavie: A little too big, but I like the motive.
SirHellsing420: Perfect size, good motive, good quality. Thumbs up.
Cyz: Too large, nice motive though.
SasuraiHell: Don't like the choice of color, but still thumbs up. :)

itachikun: great picture! 9/10

JoJo- Very nice, but they look cold should I give them a blanket?

Shay- Boobage nuf said

Applechewer- Nice little blurry, but umm whats that mean???

Catgirls- I love when girls look scared so poetic

2ndHandOfTime- Love the color but a little blurry

Mxg- Different from your other sigs, only thing is I can't see him good

Itachikun- I love the hand sketched look so original and kiddy at the same time

Over all they all look great.

SirHellsing420: Very cool, nice blood effect 9/10
Cyz: Ama pwns :D 8/10
Taydn: Wow..very sdeuctive but bad effect..it looks poorly cut. 6/10

Arakawa Takeshi - nice 9/10

Taydn - i agree with Arakawa Takeshi, it's a good idea but you could do better 7/10

GATX207_Blitz - hmm...... i like it but i don't know why............9/10

The1Voices: It's a'ight
6/10

arakawa takeshi: ama + cooking = awesome! -> 10/10
fox fire: nice pic of that kid from the boondocks -> 8/10

Cyz: Cute and colorful. ^^ 9/10

SirHellsing420 - Good mood, composition, everything really. 7.5/10

mxg - Visually boring, and the font looks a little jagged. 6/10

Inuzuka - is now in technicolor.

Before I start... All my beautiful Fs!!! They're gone!!!

SasuraiHell =

It's too pink. Way too pink. So pink that even the borders become invisible from all the pinkness. What the heck is wrong with you and the need to use the color pink. Oh, I see, it's to match Sakura's hair. Well here's a tip, when you're making a border, how about you make it stand out from the rest of the picture? When you buy a frame for a painting, do you use a green border with a green picture? NO! It blends in too much and looks terrible. The font for "Promise" isn't too great either. It's much too plain. There's no emotions in the font, I'm not feeling the word "Promise". A sad attempt to make a Naruto signture.

F

Cyz =

Ugh... Boring. I've seen too many of these in my 2 years on these forums... and everyone that was there that time *coughmantidor* should know all about these cute girl stuff...

F

2ndHandofTime =

Borderless, and blurry. Boring Font. And heck, the font isn't even in the middle. You're name is missing also. What a terrible attempt at a signature.

F

MXG =

Is it just me or the G looks really jagged? It doesn't even look like it came from the same font type you used. If you're going to make a letter look different, make it all the way to the extreme side. The character is really too small, and I can't make out his face. Sadly I lost my Mewtwo signature, and that's how you put a character on the side of a signature. Clear, large, and easily reconizable. Youre name fails to make an impression. It's hid all the way in the corner, away from everything else, and with that, creates a lot of useless space. Useless space is in definition the empty area from the Y and your name.

F

SirHellsing420 =

At least you had some originality to use a guy instead of the masses of cute girl signatures running around... Kinda boring though... doesn't look like you really did much to this signature. It's a nice crop I'll give you that, but it lacks that flare that a signature needs to make it stand out.

F

Kaminix = There's a reason nobody rated you from the time you posted until my post? It is simply terrible.

F

Taydn = Too blurry, small, and a failed attempt at ecchi. There's just no creativity in it. It'll be better if it's a avatar, but as a signature... ehhh... nothing impressive at all.

F

Arakawa Takeshi = Another cute girl signature. But this time it has a fading heart. Which does add to something. But the fade is terrible. The AT and the heart comes out at different times, and suddenly dissapears. The heart comes out too fast for the AT and both fade away too quickly to make it look nice.

Another shades of green wouldn't hurt either. Hell, another color besides green would do it good. Might I add, NEED NEW FONT?

F

The1Voices = You make my eyes bleed.

F

Fox Fire = Let's throw a bunch of random shit and call it a background. Lets not even add a border, and create a huge gaping space that could easily be filled with something like your name. But since I like huge gaping spaces and a tiny ass name that requires people to squint to look at it must be good.

F