Rate That Avatar!
 

The previous version of this thread can be found here.

Thread Rules:

1. If you post here, you have to rate an avatar. Please remember…this thread isn’t for personal chats. You must rate someone’s avatar every time you post.
   
   Example Rating System: (just an example)
   
   http://img386.imageshack.us/img386/2...eep22021hp.gif
   Catgirls: 7.6/10 - Not bad, but not your best work. A bit murky and the border is too typical for your skill level.
   
   http://img386.imageshack.us/img386/5473/aoi1005sk.gif
   NoSanninWa - 9.1/10 - Out of all the avatars I've seen you use, that's my favorite. I love the composition and the use of GIF transparency.
   
   http://img378.imageshack.us/img378/2...sojisan3yk.jpg
   xris - Hmmm...there's something different about your usual avatar but I can't put my finger on it. 8.6/10
   
   
2. Please be polite and constructive when rating other people’s avatars. Curt assessment such as "That’s crap." or "Sucks." are useless and unwelcome. Try to give the person you're rating some useful feedback.
   
   
3. Have fun and be creative. :)

Catgirls: I like the simple loop. Not too flashy, yet distinct and noticeable.

How did you create the rounded-edge border?

@ catgirls http://img386.imageshack.us/img386/2...eep22021hp.gif

lol aren't you being a bit weird rating yourself like that? I don't understand what you mean by "borders skill level" :p cause I think your border is quite the thing. Its rounded and..red. Right. Okay I get your point I guess.

As for xris's avi its the same it always been but with Santa's gear. :o

I'm confused on which thread to post in? Well I guess this one will get merged so it doesn't matter.

Catgirls- I'm not really into the cute girl anime charcters with ears but the avatar is simple and it loops. 8/10

Raikage- I don't remember you changing your av before the hack or ever for that matter, we need something new! 6.5/10

JoJo and the loli's 7/10

@Catgirls - Nekomaid Primula *faints* I love it *huggles the screen* :heh:

Tommy as always extremely disturbing...

JOJOS'STAR aww its so cute

Tabris, that ava is so weird it's cool. A tad fast, 'tho. 8/10

I have no idea where Drake's is from...:heh:

Catgirl, 10/10, loli neko-maid primula FTW!!!

Jojo, 9/10, i love it

DingoFinder, Found the original pic off of 4chan, didn't even know who the girls were till you told. And here I thought it was CG not dolls.
neko-maid primula is jsut cute beyond words :D

@ jojos'star .. hehe nice one there 8/10 :D like the words that go with it

This is technically a resubmission... but no one can prove it! Muahaha!

Efrainman: Simple, but effective. I can tell what you're thinking with a face like that. Too small, though. 7/10

Drake: Stylish, unique, misshapen, oblique. So many advjectives. 8/10

Tommy: That clown is just disturbing. 2/10... but it's a well-looped, so... 4/10

Catgirls: Simple, effective, cute. 9/10

Catgirls:6/10 I think it's a cute avatar and I like the short but sweet loop it has. Although It's pretty simple I still like it.

JOJOS'STAR:8/10 Misleading and kinda ecchi but still tasteful. Now that's the JOJOS'STAR I remember. ^_^

Xellos-_^4/10 Lei fang and Hitomi toy figures commencing in a kiss meh.....I don't like how strange it looks, plus I don't find Avatars with toy figures attractive.

Hi this is my first time posting in this thread. *waves*

Madmus: 9/10. I really like how the character looks in this one. Too bad I don't know what anime that's from.

Hooliganj: 7.5/10. The loop seems a bit too quick and not seemless. And maybe just me but it seems a bit blurry as well. Other than that, I'm glad im not the guy in that pic. Constantly being kicked in the head... :uhoh:

Xellos-_^: 8/10. A little ero-ero, eh? :D Could use a border to make it fit with the forum a bit better.

Drake: 8.5/10. Casshern(sp?) movie avatar eh? I haven't seen the movie yet but your avatar has a cool border around it. Sets it apart from most of the square borders used (like mine, lol).

Tabris: 3/10. Not really my kind of stuff. Eating babies, stabbing people in the head, pushing people in wheelchairs down stairs and all that stuff. :upset:

EDIT: Just curious though, why was the other thread closed? Was it too big or something like that?

Drake: A bit too small, however, other than that it's flawless. 9/10

OMG! Shay where did you get that avy?! So funny and cute! Sai is everywhere on my wall! Perfect score for you: 10! :)

^_^ Thanks. I just made it like an hour ago. (First gif I've made in ages, I can't make it loop. :( But I feel like I'm learning all over again. ^^ )

Hellyhan: Rukia = Win every time. :)

Catgirls: Very nice and CUTE(^_^) avatar of Shinku you've got there. 10/10 :D

raikage: The santa hat looks a bit weird on his head but a good xmas avatar nevertheless. 8/10

JOJOS'STAR: Umm... ecchi! Or not... depending on how you look at it. :heh: 8.5/10

Tommy: That swirling tongue looks scary. Reminds me of a Hollow. :p 8/10

Tabris: Hahaha... stick figure death theatre material! :) 7.5/10

Drake: Like the unique shape and your name on the bottom-left. 7.7/10

EfrainMan: Your avatar would look better I think if it was a bit larger. 7/10

Xellos-_^: Hmm... interesting. Are those really dolls like someone else mentioned? 8.8/10

madmus: Ooh, Hazuki-chan! 8.5/10

hooliganj: Interesting scene, though the source quality isn't that good for an avatar IMO. 7/10

DingoEnderZOE2: Colors are nice and clear. 8.8/10

Kiva128: Nice closeup of her face, but maybe if the borders were 1-2 pixels less... :) 8/10

Shay: LOL it's a funny animation. 9/10

Hellychan: Another xmas avatar! I like the border, which goes well with the picture. 8.7/10

JoJo: as always nice work 9/10

Shay: love tha animation 10/10 makes me laugh.

Hellychan: Love Rukia's look very festive 8/10

Drake: Different from your usual like the name at the bottom 10/10

lwl12 - nice shinku avie - 9/10
taydn - *whistle* very uh....good indeed - 9/10

Done and done.

Shay: Funny animation indeed. But why are the ones getting kicked made of paper? 9/10

lwl12: What can I say, nice avatar...hehe. 9/10

Cyz: Nice simple animation. Sometimes simple is best. 8.5/10

Cyz: shana! 10/10

Drake: yours is pretty cool 9/10

I haven't posted in this thread in ages a whole year XD well maybe I'll start up posting more in here again....or maybe I'll slowly disappear again :\

Kiva128 - cool girl with two dots on the forehead :) - 8/10
GATX207 Blitz - creepy eye 8/10

GATX207_Blitz: Woo, wolf's rain! Kiba no less... (kiva...kiba, oh so close). 9/10

Kiva128: 9/10
Cyz: 8.5/19

Winter&Summer: Nice work! 10/10

Okay, I recently changed my avatar before it went down, I lost my avatar of Rena...

In the meantime, I am using this on a temporary basis until someone can make me a better one.

source pictures for consideration:
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y10...atter_rena.jpg
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y104/kj1980/rena.jpg
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y10...Higurashi3.jpg

Thanks in advance...

kj1980: Cute, but no nose is still freaky to me...7/10.

Winter&Summer: Dat's tight...9/10.

Cyz: Chara I <3 + cute expressin + animated cuteness = 10/10.

GATX207_Blitz: Teh eye rocks. I like the top and bottom borders...9/10.

Tommy : LoL, you avatar wins. 10/10

Drake : Nice, is the avatar intentionally shaped like a 'D'? 9.2/10

Shay : Kudos for being able to squeeze so many frames into 50kb. 8.7/10

Winter&Summer : Very nice design. 9/10



I should issue a warning for my avatar:

"ITS A TRAP!!1!"

Tommy - Great loop wit the tongue, but urk... ^^; 7.5/10

Catgirls: ~ Rim-Chan ava~ How couldn't I love it :heh: Nice loop & good image quailty :)

Tommy: Always Great to look at you Avatar for more wild loops, and this one is Crazy and Great!

Shay: Different and kinda cool ^^

Hellychan: Same Girl as your last Avatar ;) ,has an interesting border & I love that purple hair :cool:

raikage: I'm feeling a need to change my Avatar a little, blend into alot of the current christmas trend :heh: Still love the guys expression on your avatar ;)

evil samurai: Still primula ? well 10/10
Riker: Omg it's a trap run!! lol 10/10

Riker: Yet another play on Internet Explorer from you, that said I found it funny when compared to your title. ^___^ 8/10

kj1980: I never noticed that Rena had no nose until someone else pointed it out, her eyes were always what made me look at your avatar, and keep looking at it. ~ 8/10 again

cyz: Very nice animation, smooth and well looped ~ 8.5/10

As for myself, I just borrowed this image from Matthew's Anime Blog until I can get home and take my own image...

JOJO: Ah, my little guys hentai-affection 8.7/10
Drake: CASSHERN!!!!! 9/10. I still have the DVD but havent watched it
MarcusG: 11/10. I crack up everytime I see that avatar. It's so funny
Shay: 9/10. Good to see Sai doesnt take that crap from Hikaru.
________
VAPIR ONE

cyz: 8.5/10 - I like both the character both the animation
kj1980: 8.5/10 - Hontou wa kawaii desu! ;)
Riker: 9/10 - Where is your Samara gone ?:twitch: LOL I was fascinated by her .. btw this one is very... attractive :D
Winter & Summer: 10/10 Very nice for choice of colours and for overall work. Good
evil-samurai: 10/10 I like the effects you got. It seems like it's shining. Very good work
Midnyt: 9/10 Kawaii indeed! ^_^

Doh~ I remember that scene now! (It's been so long since this fabulous series ended, but Sai will always stay one of my favorites, I can see him at 5 spots in my room :D ) And about the loop, I think that watery effect is rather nice and fits in very well ^^

lwl12: It seems like everybody loves that series, so I should give it a try :p I like the original colouring art, and you cropped it just perfectly, 8,5/10 :D

Taydn: Well, this girl is...hmm...interesting ^^; I don't think the use of transparency was necessary here, but I like the theme of colours, which fits Christmas well, 7/10 :)

raikage: I love how you've converted your usual avatar into a festive one :D 8/10 :)

Riker: LOL! Your avatars never cease to amuse me. Indeed, it's a trap! :heh: 9/10 :)

evil-samurai: I'm glad that you love the purple :D Your avatar has a very nice moonlight tone, the border goes very well with it. And who don't like that cuty Primula? :p 9/10 ^^

Itachikun: Bring back your avatar already! Those two brothers's expression always makes me laugh :heh:

Winter&Summer: Loving the manga panel look. 9.5/10

Hellychan: Valentine Rukia with nice border = win. 9/10

Pellissier: The loop is not seemless since there's a quick blank frame or two before it starts over again. Couldn't hurt to maybe put a border (don't have to). Looks pretty nice other than that though. 7.5/10

kj1980: Not familiar with the character myself but looks pretty good. Perhaps the one with the clever might spice things up a bit. :) 8.5/10

EfrainMan: Rectangular avatar, not very common now-a-days. The lines look a bit pixalated to me however. Rukia seems to be a popular character (haven't seen much of bleach myself). 8/10

Riker: More ero-ero avatars, hehe. And thank god that scroll bar doesn't work. lol. 8/10

seiftis: I like this one a lot for some reason. The colours, the border, they work well together. 9.5/10

evil-samurai: Mashiro...I think (unless there's someone else that looks exactly like her :)) This one's good except that I'm not a big fan of the big streaky "X" thingy going over her face. 8/10

Midnyt: Cute. :) Don't really know what else to say. :heh: What anime is that from? 8.5/10

It's my first self-created gif and I'm still at it, so I'm basically here to improve :)
EDIT: Border added. Also changed the two frames from black/white to olive/blue , which are the main colours of the pics.
Now I'm done with this, I've got new projects.

Thanks for suggestions :)

Ah btw, I didn't rate your avatar, since I probably missed it being on top of the page:

It's a 9/10 : a very cute and fascinating girl , and depicted in a way I particularly like ;)

Tommy You get 9/10 just cuz it's so creepy and icky. XD

Winter&Summer I love it, but I'm embarassed that I'm confused at what it is. Two people embracing, right? @_@ would love to know what's written... 8/10

There was this user (whom I think vanished after what happened) with an awesome Honey & Clover GIF avatar of Mayama smelling laundry. It killed me everytime I saw it. XD

Shay: Funny animation, I like it. :)
lw12: Not my favourite pic of Shinku, but Shinku's always Shinku, so I like it. :)
madmus: Where's your avatar from? Love it. :)
evil_samurai: I dislike the light-thingie, but otherwise it's lovely. :)
Riker: That's one of the funniest concepts I've ever seen. :D

lilith - nice purple hair. one of my fave characters from darkstalkers - 8/10
kaminix - oh! it's shana! awesomeness! - 10/10

Kaminix 9/10 .. At first glance I swore I knew that character... but then I cannot think anything plausible. It reminds me a lot of Studio Broccoli (Pita Ten) style, am I far? Could you tell me who is it? :)

edit: I've read now, it's Shana. I still haven't started that series, my bad.

kj1980 - fail for no border
Pellissier - fail for ugly

Kamnix - win for shana :D
Cyz - nize animation, cool border ('-^)b