AnimeSuki Forum - Other Kinds of shows

AnimeSuki Forum (http://forums.animesuki.com/index.php)

- Forum & Site Feedback (http://forums.animesuki.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2)

- - Other Kinds of shows (http://forums.animesuki.com/showthread.php?t=7354)

DekaMaster

2004-02-13 20:23

Other Kinds of shows

Animesuki used to only list anime. Now you list Fandubs,parody subs/dubs,parody subs. So why not subbed Jdrama and Jaction?

babbito2k

2004-02-13 20:29

There is another thread about listing dorama.

boneyjellyfish

2004-02-13 20:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by KingRanger

Animesuki used to only list anime. Now you list Fandubs,parody subs/dubs,parody subs. So why not subbed Jdrama and Jaction?

Say it with me now: "ANIMEsuki". They do list some non-anime things, but they only list those because they have popular anime counterparts.

DekaMaster

2004-02-13 23:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by boneyjellyfish

Say it with me now: "ANIMEsuki". They do list some non-anime things, but they only list those because they have popular anime counterparts.

Yes I see ANIMEsuki. But did you see what I said. ANIMEsuki lists:

Parody Subs of anime
Parody Subs of live action
Fandubs of anime
Fandubs of Live action

That the shows are based on live action is irelavant. if ANIMEsuki wants to be ANIMEsuki then stick to anime. But when you start listing fansubs of any live action it doesn't matter that is is based on anime or not. The shows are live action.

babbito2k

2004-02-13 23:26

Just go and read the other damn thread already.

edit: thanks ashibaka for hunting that old thread down.

boneyjellyfish

2004-02-13 23:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by KingRanger

I don't think you quite understand. The Live Action shows that are listed on ANIMEsuki all have ANIME counterparts. If they did not have ANIME counterparts, they probably wouldn't be listed (like most of the live action things subbed by tv-nihon, for instance).

I hope I've drilled the word ANIME into your skull enough times for you to realize what I'm getting at.

JustAnotherFan

2004-02-14 00:09

Quote:

Originally Posted by KingRanger

Parody Subs of anime
Fandubs of anime

Quote:

Parody Subs of live action
Fandubs of Live action

That the shows are based on live action [sic! JAF's note: probably should read anime] is irelavant.

1) Sorry, but I disagree. It is not irrelevant. They are based on existing Anime series. And that is exactly the link to AnimeSuki.
2) If those are listed it's a rare exception, not the norm.

I am not quite sure what your intention is. When I read your posts I get the feeling you want both Jdrama/Jaction listed on Animesuki and at the same time all the fandubs and liveaction based on anime removed.

And as boneyjellyfish mentioned there is a similar thread already.

Shii	2004-02-14 00:10

OTHER THREAD

JAppi

2004-02-14 01:02

Um, no animesuki does not list parody-subs. Otherwise Sub-par's MnI parody sub would have been added long ago.

http://a.scarywater.net/subpar ^_^

Make sure to leave me negative rep for double posting!

DekaMaster

2004-02-14 01:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by JustAnotherFan

1) As you stated "of anime", so I don't see why listing them has anything to do with Jdrama or Jaction nor do I see any problems with the Anime in AnimeSuki for them.
2) If those are listed, it's a rare exception, not the norm. I don't think there are any "fully" parody subs on AnimeSuki in addition. If so please name them so the Staff can look into that matter.

1) Sorry, but I disagree. It is not irrelevant. They are based on existing Anime series. And that is exactly the link to AnimeSuki.
2) If those are listed it's a rare exception, not the norm.

I am not quite sure what your intention is. When I read your posts I get the feeling you want both Jdrama/Jaction listed on Animesuki and at the same time all the fandubs and liveaction based on anime removed.

And as boneyjellyfish mentioned there is a similar thread already.

Heh no i want it all listed. Then they would be in all one easy to find place. And why would I want live action based on anime removed? And yes there are full parody subs listed on animesuki.

xris	2004-02-14 03:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by KingRanger

Heh no i want it all listed. Then they would be in all one easy to find place. And why would I want live action based on anime removed? And yes there are full parody subs listed on animesuki.

Hmmm, you seem to be doing a good job of not reading the other thread, or even the replies in this thread :) The answer is "no", we have no plans of including other drama or non-anime related live-action series on AnimeSuki. Maybe one day AnimeSuki will list such shows but it's not going to be in the near future.

Since their is already a thread concerning this topic in existance, I'm going to close this one.

If you really want a one stop site which includes everything you want, I would suggest that you create such a site. That way you can decide what it lists and what it doesn't. After all, this is exactly what GHDpro did.

GHDpro

2004-02-16 14:13

At present I don't have any plans to list such content.

Unlike with the current "generic anime related" group of torrents,
I would want such material to be grouped seperately if we should
start to list it in the future. But currently the scripts don't support it
and I don't have plans (or time) to modify them anytime soon.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:33.