Forum: Umineko
2014-08-30, 03:33
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
I'm assuming it was further insinuation that...
I'm assuming it was further insinuation that Beato was still holding something back, even though she claimed she was "exposing everything"
After all, Lambda basically just told Bern outright that...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-04-23, 23:09
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-04-23, 14:56
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
I'm not so sure. Battler in EP8 has certainly...
I'm not so sure. Battler in EP8 has certainly presented "a gameboard", but he tries repeatedly to tell Ange that he isn't playing against her, in the traditional sense. Bern is almost definitely...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-04-22, 03:20
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
Very true, just that that's also the case for...
Very true, just that that's also the case for everybody else, as well.
Well ... he doesn't escape explosive death in EP4 ; anyone that might've guided or directed him to Kuwadorian, which he...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-04-19, 04:21
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-04-12, 21:16
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-03-24, 22:59
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-03-23, 07:33
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
Whoa, thank you very much for posting the...
Whoa, thank you very much for posting the translation. The trend continues of the manga more or less confirming what was already accepted, just rather vague, previously.
And, about the bodies, I...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-03-16, 09:34
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
The tl;dr of my perspective is that, as you...
The tl;dr of my perspective is that, as you yourself say, it's a slippery slope regarding literally every other human character. I am not doubting that Ryukishi's portrayal of Kinzo may have been ......
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-03-15, 15:41
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
Well, I mean.
"Good Kinzo", for all intents...
Well, I mean.
"Good Kinzo", for all intents and purposes, isn't real. The best we see of Kinzo is young!Kinzo in EP7, where he was barely middle aged, yet, and hadn't enterred what literally...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-01-18, 17:29
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
I can't say I find your train of thought very...
I can't say I find your train of thought very plausible, Leafsnail.
According to the scene itself, the reason for targeting Rosa was that her gun had not been fired, so we know that as soon as...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-01-15, 07:02
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-01-02, 04:15
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
I still generally agree with you, but you are...
I still generally agree with you, but you are probably overestimating how willing the adults are to try to physically force one another. That is, you seem to think that once they grab the guns that...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-12-30, 02:24
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
It's possible, yeah, since the version of Kinzo...
It's possible, yeah, since the version of Kinzo that Lion knows went considerably less bonkers, since his magic baby survived. I just generally make the assumption, since Krauss was embezzling while...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-12-29, 22:11
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
I'm not saying it isn't a valid trope, and it's...
I'm not saying it isn't a valid trope, and it's certainly an interesting idea, but at least as far as Umineko is concerned ... I've gotten the impression that Ryukishi had a solid idea of who these...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-12-28, 05:47
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
*pops back in after seeing Eva's Diary*
1....
*pops back in after seeing Eva's Diary*
1. C'mon, are people still arguing that Ryukishi specifically mischaracterized Battler for a narrative longer than War and Peace?
2. The criticism...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-09-27, 00:55
|
|
Replies: 3,726
Views: 680,008
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-09-09, 01:39
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
Hm, I think it's very fair to feel dissatisfied...
Hm, I think it's very fair to feel dissatisfied with that. Going by EP8's treatment of Genji, though (a.k.a "Oh hey I wonder what actually happened during those transitive decades to make him like...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-09-05, 23:11
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
It's highly possible that he didn't learn...
It's highly possible that he didn't learn anything from their relationship, like Renall says, and regarded Bice as a sparkling exception to his regular biases. Like, someone who casually drops...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-09-02, 00:21
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
This is definitely how you seem, from my...
This is definitely how you seem, from my perspective ; you unfortunately had spoilers, decided the solution was stupid sounding and a waste of time, and decided to squeeze through the red to find...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-09-01, 12:27
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-29, 04:07
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
I still argue that when a piece is described as...
I still argue that when a piece is described as being only able to do what's possible for them, it's just that ... on the top most level, Ryukishi has a pretty certain idea of who these people are,...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-27, 17:57
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
Oh, I'm not denying that Yasu herself has a...
Oh, I'm not denying that Yasu herself has a pretty fatalistic stance about the odds of her relationships working, it's a major source of duress for her, and that duress is/was very real.
Just, we...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-27, 17:08
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
You are disregarding the literally (literally)...
You are disregarding the literally (literally) dozens of instances of murder.
Also, her romance, at least with George, wasn't doomed at all, if she had decided to pursue it. I don't remember the...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-27, 15:50
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,739,163
I wouldn't say it's a coincidence that Shannon...
I wouldn't say it's a coincidence that Shannon and Jessica stayed friends but ... Jessica was friends with all the Fukuin servants, and Shannon is just the only one who never found another job /...
|
