Quote:
Originally Posted by FreedomMS
well..episode 1 did say it because of a certain gas incident Tatarigoroshi-hen. so i suppose keiichi is alive? cuz rena can't possibly have past memory of all the incident that happen when she was young before that gas incident
|
I don't quite understand what you mean, but the gas disaster also happened in Himatsubushi and Tsumihoroboshi. Tsumihoroboshi and Himatsubushi both occured before Reunion. Rena was the only survivor from Hinamizawa, because she wasn't there when it happened. Keiichi was a victim of the disaster this time around. Also, it's very likely the disaster happened in Onikakushi as well, since we never saw what happened to Rika at the end of it.
All we know now is that Rika being Watanagashi'd = gas disaster and Rika being killed otherwise (suicide or Shion's torture) leads to no disaster. The question you have to ask is "Why?"