Quote:
Originally Posted by Chron
So what? I could reason that Erika is really Battler's ideal self, and the problem is that that conclusion is just as reasonable as any other theory, and easily just as supported in the text.
|
I'd say no it isn't. You're possibly confusing "proof" with "evidence".
There's plenty of evidence against Erika being Battler's perfect self (chiefly: Battler thinks Erika is a complete bitch).
Crucial point: a theory can be more valid than another theory even if it isn't proved to be true.