Quote:
Originally Posted by FierceAlchemist
Let's not forget that even in the Madoverse a good number of magical girls just died and didn't go to heaven with Madoka. She only took the ones who fell into despair, not the ones who were outright killed in battle. If the Law of Cycles has lost all its humanity then it is a big loss for magical girls, one I think would motivate Madoka to fight, but it's not nearly as bad as them becoming witches.
|
I think it's a very good argument that can be used against Madoverse. Magical girls, whether they will turn witch or not, help protect people against witches. Why only girls with corrupted Soul Gem receive blessings from "God Madoka" and spend eternity in Madoka's heaven? The anime or movie hasn't shown what happens to girls who are killed in battle or get their soul gems broken before. It would be interesting if the sequel introduces a new cast and shows two different factions of magical girls: one with Sayaka or Madoka and the other with Homura, all fighting when the world is falling apart.