AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - [Game] Umineko

Renall · 2010-03-25, 02:38

Ryukishi claims the mystery (I assume the overall thing) was solvable as of ep4. Assume that's true.

So when ep5 comes out, that leaves four possible states for ep5:

Solvable by itself, using only ep5.
Solvable only with help from ep1-4.
Not solvable without future Chiru episodes.
Not solvable at all.

Most of these would require help. That said, ep1 is solvable entirely without future episodes (all you give up for ep1 is some red text, most of which doesn't hinder the more obvious theory anyway). I would argue ep3 is also solvable by itself. So at least one episode is solvable on its own. That doesn't mean any given episode is, however.

2010-03-25, 02:38	Link #7037
Renall BUY MY BOOK!!! Join Date: May 2009	Ryukishi claims the mystery (I assume the overall thing) was solvable as of ep4. Assume that's true. So when ep5 comes out, that leaves four possible states for ep5: Solvable by itself, using only ep5. Solvable only with help from ep1-4. Not solvable without future Chiru episodes. Not solvable at all. Most of these would require help. That said, ep1 is solvable entirely without future episodes (all you give up for ep1 is some red text, most of which doesn't hinder the more obvious theory anyway). I would argue ep3 is also solvable by itself. So at least one episode is solvable on its own. That doesn't mean any given episode is, however.