Quote:
Originally Posted by LyricalAura
Whenever Beatrice says that someone exists in a location, such as a room, or the island, she is referring to the physical location of their body. So, the statement in EP3 that "when the five victims were killed, the culprit was in the same room" means that for each victim, the body owned by the culprit and the body owned by the victim were in the same room. All bodies are trivially co-located with themselves! Therefore, since Shannon and Beatrice owned the same body at the time Beatrice murdered Shannon, they were in the same room, regardless of who was active or not!
|
But under #1, Beatrice
cannot murder Shannon. It isn't actually possible. Shannon can't even die. She just isn't actively controlling the body. Being out of power is not the same as being dead and it is impossible to make irrevocable. Even if Shannon never appears again for the rest of the body's life, it technically doesn't mean she was irrevocably destroyed, merely that she was never reasserted. That's not the same thing as dying.