Thread
:
Umineko no Naku Koro ni - Episode 4 Discussion / Poll
View Single Post
2009-07-23, 01:09
Link
#
104
ameskitty
Kupo
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Sleeping
Age: 32
Spoiler
for
ep 1-4
:
Ick, there was so much potential for moving the asthma scene to after Kanon's death - and props to DEEN for thinking of it - but they just butchered it :/. Didn't help that they continued with Jessica's total character deficiency. (and my non-VN-reading friend commented that it seemed like she was randomly coughing in despair, which is a WTF no matter how you look at it)
The only scene where people reacted in a natural/non-linear fashion was the Eva/Hideyoshi scene - everything else seemed like something from a badly-acted play where the secondary actors just stand there stoically and let the leads get all emotional.
On the bright side, both Kanon's face-off with Beatrice and Maria's singing were both pure epic win (ahaha.wav was very shocking). And the scenes in Kinzo's study were not bad at all.
Am I strange for liking Maria's expressions, at least in this episode?
Foo...I guess 6/10
7/10 if it weren't for the subtlety fail that is "DURR she liked him didn't she?"...it really bothered me for some reason :/
.
Bring on episode 1-5?
ameskitty
View Public Profile
Send a private message to ameskitty
Find More Posts by ameskitty