Quote:
Originally Posted by felix
And some of you who reponded aren't exactly angels yourselves; so let's not go there.
|
Well, we aren't starting a topic that makes us somewhat hypocritical and makes the topic less credible
Anyways seeing that you also have a neutral view on this, then i would say that the arguments on the first page for this petition are definitely not neutral at all and are shortly summarized as this:
- the majority of the people (in your case: fans) have no interests in reading the rants, so rants are off topic in their opinion.
- rants polarizes the discussion and leads to possible flame wars or something else.
- there is no point in complaining, because a show is what it is.
- rants are insulting to the fanbase
All of these arguments simply suggests that the fans can't accept criticism and that haters should stay out of their topic and rant somewhere else (like in your suggestion a separate topic or doing that in blogs).That's sounds like pure censorship to me.
You claim not to target critics or discussion on the flaws, but your example of using Reckoner actually says otherwise. His rant was purely based on his critical view of the flaws of that episode and the serie itself.
Also how can you start such a biased petition, while you are actually neutral on this?