View Single Post
Old 2011-02-04, 14:08   Link #65
dahak
Utu Class Planetoid
 
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Reading, UK
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaijo View Post
They didn't now when the threat of Carim's prophecy would end, so they probably just said, "uh, 1 year" to the upper brass. Thus they lasted 1 year.
Genya said HQ wanted to keep RF6 operational and it was Hayate's decision to shut down, supposedly due to her belief she wasn't skilled enough to run it.

Carim also mentioned that RF6 would have to succeed in cases after the Relics case to survive, back during the Train incident. Though she might have been referring to the prophecy.

Back to the previous discussion
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaijo
But Cypha plainly said she had moved, and then asked what Signum would do. That put the ball in Signum's court, and we see what Signum's choice of action was.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nanya01
Except that is Cyper attacking and Signum blocking. Signum is still vertical, but Cypher is leaning forward. You don't lean forward into other peoples attacks when blocking, but you do lean towards them on a lunge, so Cypher was attacking.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nanya01
I note you've missed the previous page where Signum says Cypher is stronger than expected. The one that tells us Signum knows Cypher is stronger than the average flight capable mage at this point and can fly. Even Fate in her high speed modes has some defenses.

Quote:
Originally Posted by 00-Raiser
And yet when they see how Thoma chooses to go off and die, they call him a pansy emo kid.
Weird, I remember calling that one of the two ethical options Thoma tried to take.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiresias
And speaking of unrealistic, this is the series where a 19-year old can become a lieutenant colonel, as if military ranks are the new power level (you're supposed to promote an officer based on her command skill and experience, not by the ability to shoot big laser beams)...
She has roughly 10 years in service at the beginning of StrikerS doesn't she?

Assuming ten years service in the US Army, it isn't unusual to have reached Major. So she's only one rank high. British Army I understand has different limits and Lt Colonel might be theoretically possible in 10 years.

It might be better if she was a Major but it isn't more than a grade out. And the Imperial Japanese Military [to name an example that might have influenced the writers] had a policy that officers decorated for conspicuous gallantry could be excused a time in grade requirement and end up a rank [or possibly more] ahead of where the usual restrictions would place them.

Of course TSAB as we know has a rule that limits recognition of that sort to units.
dahak is offline   Reply With Quote