[Renall]

Originally Posted by ALPHA-Beatrice

-Current Thesis:
Even if he isn't the culprit, it's possible that Krauss was an accomplice of the culprit or that he could have killed people during the time Lady Bernkastel hadn't made the declaration(the same solution Battler had for Eva-Beatrice's riddle).

If Genji is Rosa's accomplice, I also argued that just because Genji was "out of the mansion", doesn't necessarily negate any actions he could've done while walking out of the mansion or being in the mansion's vicinity.

• Why is Krauss allowing Natsuhi to be terrorized by the MF19YA? Also, who is the MF19YA out of the group of Rosa, Krauss, and Genji? What is the point of doing anything to Natsuhi if Krauss is an accomplice? What was Krauss's motive for helping anyone?
• What was the point of the letter or the story about a letter existing, whether or not it actually did? Who would have to be complicit in this story? Why would some of those apparent non-accomplices be involved?
• Why didn't Hideyoshi recognize the person he supposedly saw in the bedroom who "killed" him?
• If Battler solved the epitaph, what was anyone's motive to kill anyone? Especially given that anyone in the cousins' room would have more motive to murder Battler (who was sleeping all night, as Erika confirmed) than the other occupants of the room? Why wasn't he killed, or why did nobody suggest he was responsible (aside from Erika confirming his alibi)?
• What exactly was Erika doing here in general? Who was she working with, if anybody? If she was focusing on Natsuhi, why? Why take steps to frame Natsuhi ahead of time for a detective nobody even knew was coming?
• Why did Eva take steps to establish Genji's alibi? Why didn't Genji do anything that night (he wouldn't be aware of the seal until he'd broken it)?
• The bodies never moved after they died. Which means everyone presumably left the cousins' room of their own volition. Where were they going, under whose authority or idea, and why?
• What exactly makes you believe that anyone was actually murdered in ep5?