View Single Post
Old 2010-12-18, 02:41   Link #19874
Cross Clown
rule 63, pl0x
Join Date: Aug 2008
To be honest, I think Jan-poo is just looking for a fight. She's being contrary and combative for the sake of being contrary and combative.

Anyways, I agree with Renall on most of his points about themes, narratives, and especially that segment on Kanon and Shannon.

The narrative in Umineko is shaky at best, and as per knox rules, it's only the detectives perspective (Battler & Erika's) that should be trusted.

Aren't we given the whole "cat box" routine with every episode anyways? I'm not sure what Jan-poo is trying to argue with since the narrative in Umineko is something that's only subject to interpretation rather than taking it to heart.
Cross Clown is offline   Reply With Quote