[crazysjd89]

Originally Posted by Jan-Poo

Spoiler for Eva beatrice:

One is the thing you just said, however in doing that Eva would need to change her reconstruction of the facts. She claims that Nanjo was killed by a "human with magical powers" and what she has shown to Battler in the meta world is that that "human with magical powers" was her.

Spoiler for response:

What makes you say that? From what I gathered from it, she wasn't trying to proove it was a "human with magic powers", but more generally "magic powers were used". Simply saying some witch from off the island revived one of the dead would be sufficent to proove this, or you could say one of the dead 15 had a blessing from a witch where they were allowed to live for a bit longer. These both involve magic and a human being the murderer, and don't contradict anything as far as I can tell.

Originally Posted by Jan-Poo

Spoiler for Episode 3:

As the possible culprit, Maria is at the bottom of the list because there's no possible way a 9 year old girl could kill that many people without magic or supernatural. Unless she's a esper or unless she's able to hypnotize people @_@, anyway you'd need at least some degree of "fantasy" to place her as the villain. Then again Maria definitely died in the 3rd episode and several other deaths happened afterwards (yet hypnosis could still work...).

Spoiler for response:

Hypnosis is an interesting thought, and could be used to explain "motivation" of the murderer, but not of the culprit (the one doing hypnotizing). It doesn't help solve it in a human way, but it's still an interesting thought.