Quote:
Originally Posted by ErenselTheJester
I don't think a promise is guaranteed, its more than likely that its a mere event disguised as a promise to Beatrice and Ryukishi is pulling a wool over our eyes.
|
Here's the thing - Battler's sin has to be in EP 1-4. It is extremely hinted that Beatrice has an issue with promises: she thinks breaking one is the worst thing a human can do, she says she would never break one and when Battler says he never remembered making a promise to her she says she wants to die. Hell there was an entire song at the end of EP 5 about making a
promise for love when Beatrice evaporates and is dead.
One small red herring is something, but Ryukishi is literally THROWING hints about a promise being the sin. EP 6 when the mysterious narrator talks about making "Beatrice" it even mentions waiting for a promise to be fulfilled.