I don't mind Shinobu voice, not that there's to much to judge
(and of course I didn't read the novels).
With the drama cd I found this little tribute/crossover (and probably the best MAD about
bakemonogatari I've seen floating around)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcybcUOqi6g
Sorry if it's a repost (it's difficult to keep track of all this messages
)