[Chaos2Frozen]

Originally Posted by Westlo

Of course it has sold more, it has way more novels released, so that goes without saying. I mean c'mon, you don't see someone go Anime series A sold 13 volumes x 10,000 so a better seller than anime series B which sold 6 volumes x 21,000.

I didn't.

All I said was that it "make up for that by selling more than double the total sales".

I never said anything about which is better or worse.

In fact, the original topic you raised was who made the more money.

Originally Posted by Westlo

Also Monogatari novels make more $$$ than Index, they sell about the same but for double the price nearly.

So did the price of the Monogatari novels make up for the 14 million books sold?

EDIT:

Originally Posted by Westlo

And all Japanese companies used shipped numbers since sold to supplier = sold to them, but it doesn't mean sold to consumer. See manga circulation numbers, something like Assassination Classroom should be selling a million copies per volume but Oricon shows that vol 4 is going to finish around 650k at its current rate.

Don't you remember the Hidan no Aria website saying crap like 2 million sold when the anime started and Oricon had volume 1 at like 90k....

By all means, use the total number of books shipped by the monogatari series then.

Otherwise, I'll be happy if you could provide a more accurate figure for the sales of both series.