Quote:
Originally Posted by relentlessflame
Well, the quantity of posts may be different, but the issues are fundamentally the same.
|
No, they're not. Because the quantity of posts makes the issues different.
You even said it yourself!:
There is so much novel comparison discussion that it could potentially fill a thread on its own, and it can distract from the topic at hand.
Very nicely and succinctly put. You are 100% right there.
That makes SAO different. Just compare SAO to, say, Hyouka. Hyouka is definitely not causing the same issues that SAO is causing. The difference is like night-and-day. And a lot of it is due to quantity of posts.
Quote:
|
In discussing the situation with the staff, we will not go for the comparison thread option at the moment,
|
So you put forward a compromise idea of your own creation. Two members openly support it.
One moderator publicly goes against the idea, and you just completely abandon it?
Why not wait to get more feedback from other AS members? Or if the moderating staff is so strongly against the idea, then why don't they publicly present their reasons for why they're against it so we can have a fair, open, and transparent discussion about it?