[Gary_A]

Originally Posted by Lost

Oooh, I understand. The repeated use of "you poor one" wasnt so justified, but in Shinku's defense, at least she wasnt saying it purposely or trying to anger Gin? I say this because I believe that she really didnt like seeing Gin in that state:

Spoiler for Screens:

This was when Gin was hugging her. I like to think that the pity she felt was at least real. (but, yeah, pity is bad - then again, Gin was in a somewhat pitiful state - tho repeating that pity over and over is worse)


This was when Gin disappeared into the ground. I dont think Shinku enjoyed it.

Also, while Shinku could have been more tactful when breaking the "news" that Gin "couldnt" become a RM to her, at least Shinku did not expressly teach Gin to walk just so Gin could meet father, i.e. she didnt purposely say or intent: "I'm teaching you to walk so you can meet father" (or did she? Remember, I know no Japanese. ). All along, it was Gin's desire to meet father that led Gin along. Anyhow, I guess thats the reason for Shinku's sad expression when Gin hugged her.. Shinku thought that Gin could not meet father.

I see.

Spoiler for :

nope, she didn't say it. and yep, Gin snapped when Shinku was in such a disbelief that a "doll like her" unfinished and "pitiful" could ever become a Rozen maiden in her somewhat exact words (I'm not a good translator really) after Suigintou introduced herself to Shinku as a Rozen maiden "That's a lie...for you to be a rozenmaiden? something like that..." "Why?" "because aren't you still unfinished, pitiful doll. The Rozenmaiden were made to aim to be the perfect girl, Alice. You're...different from us"