AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - [Game] Umineko

SeagullCrazy · 2010-05-18, 16:59

Since a theory for EP1 was just posted, I figured now might be a good time to show my theory about EP3. A lot of it came from the discussion we had many pages back regarding 07151129.
Now I'm confident in this, so let's see if it still holds up.

First Twilight:

Kanon, Shannon, Gohda, Kumasawa, and Genji planned on faking their deaths at the first twilight. They set up the magic circles and letters, and burnt Kinzo's body. Meanwhile, the adults were in the dining room the whole night. They realized that the servants were conspiring against them, and decided to get guns from Kinzo's study for protection. Then some of them went into rooms to lie down and rest. But they noticed the servants hiding, and shot them out of fear and self-defense. They opened the letters and went to each room, killing the servants out of self-defense.

Second Twilight:

Rosa, knowing that there was no killer to be afraid of, went outside with Maria to see the rose. Later, Rudolf went to check on Rosa, and found her. She told him about Eva and her finding the gold. Rudolf wanted the money and killed her in a fit of anger. Since Maria was a witness, he had to kill her too.

Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Twilights:

Since Rudolf and Kyrie knew that there was no culprit, they wanted to go to the mansion to get good food to eat. Hideyoshi came with them. When they got there, Rudolf questioned Hideyoshi about the gold. Believing in his wife, who had not told him about the gold, he said she never found it. Rudolf shot at him, but missed, and Hideyoshi killed Rudolf instead. Kyrie picked up Rudolf's gun and shot Hideyoshi. He shot her in the stomach before dying. Kyrie put stakes in the gunshot wounds, and collapsed on the floor.

Seventh and Eighth Twilights:

George jumped out the window of the guest house. Nanjo noticed that the window was open, and shut it. George suspected Krauss and Natsuhi of killing Shannon. When Eva went to wash her face, George tied a rope around their necks and strangled them. He brought their corpses to the rose garden and staked them.

Ninth Twilight:

Kyrie got up and wrote 07151129 on the door to the parlor. It was intended as a message for Nanjo, who originally told her that number. However, George got there first, and since he was conspiring with Nanjo as well, he thought it was a message from Nanjo to him. He went into the parlor, and Kyrie shot him. Then, when Nanjo was outside the servant's room, Kyrie shot him, and died from her stomach wound. Eva convinced herself she was the culprit and shot Battler.

Tenth Twilight:

Jessica died in the explosion. Eva went to Kuwadorian, where the explosion couldn't reach her.

2010-05-18, 16:59	Link #10136
SeagullCrazy Endless Witch-Doctor Join Date: Mar 2010	Since a theory for EP1 was just posted, I figured now might be a good time to show my theory about EP3. A lot of it came from the discussion we had many pages back regarding 07151129. Now I'm confident in this, so let's see if it still holds up. First Twilight: Kanon, Shannon, Gohda, Kumasawa, and Genji planned on faking their deaths at the first twilight. They set up the magic circles and letters, and burnt Kinzo's body. Meanwhile, the adults were in the dining room the whole night. They realized that the servants were conspiring against them, and decided to get guns from Kinzo's study for protection. Then some of them went into rooms to lie down and rest. But they noticed the servants hiding, and shot them out of fear and self-defense. They opened the letters and went to each room, killing the servants out of self-defense. Second Twilight: Rosa, knowing that there was no killer to be afraid of, went outside with Maria to see the rose. Later, Rudolf went to check on Rosa, and found her. She told him about Eva and her finding the gold. Rudolf wanted the money and killed her in a fit of anger. Since Maria was a witness, he had to kill her too. Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Twilights: Since Rudolf and Kyrie knew that there was no culprit, they wanted to go to the mansion to get good food to eat. Hideyoshi came with them. When they got there, Rudolf questioned Hideyoshi about the gold. Believing in his wife, who had not told him about the gold, he said she never found it. Rudolf shot at him, but missed, and Hideyoshi killed Rudolf instead. Kyrie picked up Rudolf's gun and shot Hideyoshi. He shot her in the stomach before dying. Kyrie put stakes in the gunshot wounds, and collapsed on the floor. Seventh and Eighth Twilights: George jumped out the window of the guest house. Nanjo noticed that the window was open, and shut it. George suspected Krauss and Natsuhi of killing Shannon. When Eva went to wash her face, George tied a rope around their necks and strangled them. He brought their corpses to the rose garden and staked them. Ninth Twilight: Kyrie got up and wrote 07151129 on the door to the parlor. It was intended as a message for Nanjo, who originally told her that number. However, George got there first, and since he was conspiring with Nanjo as well, he thought it was a message from Nanjo to him. He went into the parlor, and Kyrie shot him. Then, when Nanjo was outside the servant's room, Kyrie shot him, and died from her stomach wound. Eva convinced herself she was the culprit and shot Battler. Tenth Twilight: Jessica died in the explosion. Eva went to Kuwadorian, where the explosion couldn't reach her.