[Judoh]

Originally Posted by chronotrig

@Renall:

Spoiler for size:

...There's that word again. "Provable". The last time you said "you can't start making a theory unless you prove everything first", I managed to explain the entire opening of EP2. Now, I've taken the final scene from that game and shown that it explains most of the magic scenes for the murders in EP2 as long as you know about the gold text. Again, you say that "magic scenes prove nothing, so they should be ignored", and I say that "Ryuukishi added those magic scenes for a reason".

Even if your sure how the colored texts work how can you be sure that that is used on the episode 2 gameboard? Before episode 5 we didn't even know that colored text could be used by the pieces, and we didn't even know about colored text until after the first twilight. So how does a theory about colored text explain how Beatrice can convince Battler that magic exists when the clues only existed recently? I can understand that you want to beleive that scene happened, but why do you need to use that theory to explain why he accepted it? Why can't your Beatrice just say "this is how I killed everyone I did this this and this?" Why does it have to be colored text?