Quote:
Originally Posted by cmos
He used the first rule twice, which is basically Knox's 8th. His 11th rule was used in some other story, different from Umineko. And the 7th "there must be a corpse" doesn't say anything about the means of death. When did he said his rules about accidents/suicides in red? Probably because they don't apply he can't say them in red.
|
Can't and didn't are two very different things.
Quote:
Oh, ok, I see how you could make it work. Small bombs logic in use is a wonderful solution, definitely better than Shkannotrice. 
|
My point is not that it's a better theory, just that Shkanon can't be taken as the one single solution. You can't deny it either. The only way to win this game is with a theory machine gun, rather than the sniper rifle you use in most mystery novels. Also c'mon, smashed head is a bit better than small bombs! Just a bit!