[Ryus]

Originally Posted by MAX_COLA_POWER!

Spoiler for contradiction:

One Problem with your hoody theory Ryus, if she really is Hisui, then why did she cry when she saw Natsu fight in the arena? Why did she tighten her lip when she passed FT's lodgings? Why did she write in her journal with her bad hand when Hisui cleary has both arms? Why did Jellal look in shock when he saw who it was? Only reason because, it's somebody we already know, and it's somebody that has only bad memories about the Eclipse Plan, when Hisui is clearly in favor of it. You gotta remember those small details.

And speaking of which

Spoiler for 311:

Chapter's out, Hisui=Hoody theory proved wrong.

Speculation

Spoiler for spec on ch 311:

its quite simple really. The robbed chick is her future self who traveled into the past to warn everyone about tomorrow.

See still works... and rather well (did I mention she has a time machine that can't be destroyed by magic since it absorbs it... so palace blowing up only char ages it really well.) How else would she learn about tomorrow unless someone she trusted went there and came back from it. And who could be more trusted than yourself... and who would need to avoid being spotted by the guards, simple your half blown up future self. Why she like Natsu? She meet him in the future. You know maybe I had already covered those small details already. Future Levi was scared so why not future Hisui too?

Simply put, this plot concept happened in Rave Master, hiro's last manga where a character from the future came back to warn everyone... they all died. Hiro is once again using a very similar plot point from his last series in FT again.

Now my theory isn't perfect mind you, since I have no idea how the Jade stuff fits in there.