Quote:
Originally Posted by Renall
*snip*
|
I really thought the same thing as I read Umineko 6. It's totally absurd for Battler to intentionally do exactly what Erika wants him to every single time. I mean, there's no way he thought Erika would fall for fake deaths as the major trick TWICE IN A ROW. After that was exactly what caused her downfall in the previous game, Battler would have to be even less competent than he was in Episode 2 to be earnestly trying.
Furthermore, if
Kanon is Kinzo, (which is the only solution to the Logic Error I can think of that doesn't involve a certain irritating theory) the only ones who would know would be Grandfather, Meta-Battler, Kanon himself, and Kanon's Beatrice - Shannon. Even if Erika is Shannon, Meta Erika is not inside Shannon's head. So Meta Erika wouldn't know. But Beatrice would, so that's why Battler used this mystery. It doesn't reveal the true nature of Beatrice, which is something Battler expressly refuses to do. What it does do is call on something no one else could know.