Quote:
Originally Posted by james0246
Are we just creating a thread filled with reviews of each series (etc) and no discussion? Or are we trying to come up with some sort of official review for every series (plus manga, novels, games, music, etc)? In which case we are choosing the best review from the thread, which also becomes more about the poster than the series.
|
The first approach might be a better idea, since using a piece as an
official review almost becomes the reputation system all over again. But I would specify creating one review thread for each series that doesn't have its own subforum, as Archon suggested. To that end...
Quote:
Originally Posted by james0246
Personally, I think summaries would be a better avenue for potential new viewers rather than actual reviews...but then the Suggestion sub-forum is already built to handle such posts, though only if a poster there knows what they want to see.
|
...the first post in every thread would have the summary, the rest of the thread is dedicated to reviews.
IE,
[series name] review thread
OP has summary
following posts are dedicated to reviews
And what about series subforums moved to
Retired? Should the review subforums have a sticky thread listing which series those are?