Quote:
Originally Posted by Laserworm
But in Umineko we are mostly assuming everything...
|
Now we are not Quit making stuff up. We have to take the context of the white red and blue and gold text into account as well as the hints in the story. Hints =/= assumptions. And most of the theories here are based on clues. Shkanon makes quite a lot of assumptions that something is true based on a a couple of hints. So does Erika not existing, but that requires less assumptions. Kanon escaping the location check is an entirely different thing though.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jan-Poo
without shkanon you need
One theory explaining how it is possible that Erika doesn't exist.
One theory explaining how kanon escaped from the sealed room (usually Kanon-Kinzo)
One theory explaining how Kanon "magically" disappeared from the closed room
One theory explaining the meaning of the whole "love test".
|
Erika ghost and Kanon rescuing Battler are two completely different things. One is just more complicated then the other.
Here is my claim. I don't need to automatically explain why Kanon was able to do it. The fact is that it was proclaimed that Kanon rescued Battler in red. So either no hints are required to come to the conclusion that Kanon rescued Battler or there must exist hints that we are not seeing due to Knox's 8th. This is true with and without Shkanon.
How he disappeared from the closed room is a moot point.