Quote:
Originally Posted by Jan-Poo
Jessica was with Nanjo when he treated Kanon. How come Jessica didn't notice a thing?
|
I always just figured Jessica was fooled by some good acting and a lot of fake blood.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jan-Poo
How could Kumasawa, Nanjo and Genji be so condescending about a plan involving their own death?
|
You mean "consenting", right? I agree, I'm not so certain they would volunteer to die. Maybe Genji, but that's it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jan-Poo
A popular theory is that there was a fake murder conspiracy. So basically pretty much everyone except Battler enacted a serial murder scenario believing no one was going to really die, but then Yasu killed the victims for real once they've been isolated. This is hinted in EP5 and EP6 where the first twilight victims are clearly not dead when discovered but everyone say they are.
|
The idea has merit, but it would require some hard-to-swallow assumptions at some parts, like Gohda and Rosa believing that the whole Halloween scene in episode 2 was fake.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jan-Poo
It is. The boiler room doesn't have any window. The boiler room is underground.
|
*sigh* Duh. I know that. You're not following my train of argument. What I am trying to say is that the boiler room door is not the
only entrance not explicitly said to be locked, yet you're obsessed over that one entrance. The
only reason it gets more scrutiny is because you are
assuming that one (arguably not) ambiguous line in episode 1 says that the door has no lock on it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kani
Where did he explain this? That's quite a complicated murder. I wonder how he could think we would be able to guess something like that?
|
It's actually borrowed from a famous murder Mystery novel. You could guess it if you were a Mystery reader.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cao Ni Ma
Rosa most certainly checked the door before going in. Remember, she goes to the trouble of getting the key and opening the door. She also had no need to lie about meeting Kinzo either, that is if she wasnt trying to hide something. The problem I have with Rosa in here is that it doesn't feel like she's covering for Shkanon. She even goes and fingers Kanon as being the most likely culprit in Jessica's murder and ostracizes the rest of the servants because she quite logically suspects something wrong with them. Well it could all be a some sort of eleventh dimensional chess thing going on to trick Battler  |
Rosa probably received instruction from Beatrice anonymously; she probably doesn't know who Beatrice actually is.