Quote:
Originally Posted by bladeofdarkness
but that was not the point of the scenes
when you kill off a character you do it for a reason
you want their deaths to effect the plot
in this case bringing them back (un-deathing them if you prefer) cancels the change and ruins it completly
suppose for a sec that sherly came back to life
would that be a good thing for sherly fans
probably (some would see it my way)
would this be a good thing for the plot
not at all
and this is what they did with nunnaly's death (the one death that should have had the most impact)
|
You are being illogical again:
- We see shirly die, we do not see Nunnaly die.
- Nunnaly's "Death" was always questionable (two shuttles). Therefore it is not so shocking that she returned.
Their "deaths" are far too different to compare.