AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - [Game] Umineko

RandomAvatarFan · 2013-02-11, 16:53

Yeah, I don't think many people would have picked up the source material if their introduction to it was a complete failure of an adaptation.

My point is that I'm willing to say that Ryukishi probably did work with the creation of it, maybe not as close as the manga, but close enough that perhaps certain changes may have been intentional.

Check out Kanon's anime death in EP1. Watch it. By the time Nanjo and Battler come in, the stake isn't even piercing Kanon. I already gave mention about the appearance of the gold ingot, how it even appears unfinished. The map of Rokkenjima in EP4, Watch the preview for the third episode (It plays WorldEnd, and is narrated by Shannon). I was in tears.

My point is that it's possible that some changes in the anime could actually be an additional clue, like how we've been viewing changes in the manga, as opposed to an absolute screw up.

2013-02-11, 16:53	Link #31876
RandomAvatarFan Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2011	Yeah, I don't think many people would have picked up the source material if their introduction to it was a complete failure of an adaptation. My point is that I'm willing to say that Ryukishi probably did work with the creation of it, maybe not as close as the manga, but close enough that perhaps certain changes may have been intentional. Check out Kanon's anime death in EP1. Watch it. By the time Nanjo and Battler come in, the stake isn't even piercing Kanon. I already gave mention about the appearance of the gold ingot, how it even appears unfinished. The map of Rokkenjima in EP4, Watch the preview for the third episode (It plays WorldEnd, and is narrated by Shannon). I was in tears. My point is that it's possible that some changes in the anime could actually be an additional clue, like how we've been viewing changes in the manga, as opposed to an absolute screw up. __________________ Without love this picture cannot be seen.