AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - [Game] Umineko no Naku Koro ni

Squirrellord · 2009-06-07, 15:18

Long response for izmosmolnar

Spoiler for Everything:

-As furniture who know magic, it's quite possible that Genji, Shannon, and Kanon all are able to perceive that they are constantly being reborn. However, they are also bound (as furniture) to allow the ceremony to begin, and thus can only hope to survive until the end, not ruin it.
-Helicopter's need a landing space, and Rokkenjima is covered with forests, hills, and (at least) two mansions. I don't think there'd be a space big enough for a helicopter, though (Devil's Proof), there's no way to deny it.
-Witches are being which transcend humans. Looking at Eva Beatrice (and Bernkastel, if she's the same one we think she is), the human remains, but a meta-witch is spawned. So if Virgilia is actually the witch incarnation of someone (my theory is Kumasawa when she was younger, as seen by Beatrice), then Kinzo could summon her. Much like Maria and Sakutaro, Kinzo knows that Beatrice is dead, and cannot just re-summon her, he has to go through all this trouble to accept her as being alive. Also, of course, the fact that KINZO IS DEAD, and he cannot summon anything at all!
-We don't know what Battler's sin is, it's something other than him leaving the family, but it directly impacted the events of 1986.
-This is another hotly debated topic... it's possible Beatrice only granted Battler the ability to use red for a short while. It's possible that Battler has enough sportsmanly pride that he won't simply end the game by literally using the opponent's move. It could be he can only say things he knew for sure, and since he technically did or did not come out of Asumu's vagina, whether he remembered it or not himself, part of him knew that fact in a way.
-Who says somebody was impersonating Kinzo in part 1? Natsushi saw him, but can she be trusted? And quite, why is Nanjo there? He should definitely know. Though it's possible that he's been hired on by Krauss to keep the illusion up. Who better to make the family believe he's alive than to have a trusted doctor say so?
-Because being told to pay attention to the font color tooootally keeps us immersed lol
-That's just a flub. When you start getting really into scenes like that, it's common to make mistakes, both in translating and editing :P

2009-06-07, 15:18	Link #986
Squirrellord Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2006	Long response for izmosmolnar Spoiler for Everything: -As furniture who know magic, it's quite possible that Genji, Shannon, and Kanon all are able to perceive that they are constantly being reborn. However, they are also bound (as furniture) to allow the ceremony to begin, and thus can only hope to survive until the end, not ruin it. -Helicopter's need a landing space, and Rokkenjima is covered with forests, hills, and (at least) two mansions. I don't think there'd be a space big enough for a helicopter, though (Devil's Proof), there's no way to deny it. -Witches are being which transcend humans. Looking at Eva Beatrice (and Bernkastel, if she's the same one we think she is), the human remains, but a meta-witch is spawned. So if Virgilia is actually the witch incarnation of someone (my theory is Kumasawa when she was younger, as seen by Beatrice), then Kinzo could summon her. Much like Maria and Sakutaro, Kinzo knows that Beatrice is dead, and cannot just re-summon her, he has to go through all this trouble to accept her as being alive. Also, of course, the fact that KINZO IS DEAD, and he cannot summon anything at all! -We don't know what Battler's sin is, it's something other than him leaving the family, but it directly impacted the events of 1986. -This is another hotly debated topic... it's possible Beatrice only granted Battler the ability to use red for a short while. It's possible that Battler has enough sportsmanly pride that he won't simply end the game by literally using the opponent's move. It could be he can only say things he knew for sure, and since he technically did or did not come out of Asumu's vagina, whether he remembered it or not himself, part of him knew that fact in a way. -Who says somebody was impersonating Kinzo in part 1? Natsushi saw him, but can she be trusted? And quite, why is Nanjo there? He should definitely know. Though it's possible that he's been hired on by Krauss to keep the illusion up. Who better to make the family believe he's alive than to have a trusted doctor say so? -Because being told to pay attention to the font color tooootally keeps us immersed lol -That's just a flub. When you start getting really into scenes like that, it's common to make mistakes, both in translating and editing :P